When is civil disobedience justified?

Discussion in 'The Intelligence Cell' started by SkiCarver, Jun 21, 2009.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. I have been thinking that the current government are contemptable and a number of their policies severely compromise basic democratic principles. Not least in this is the transfer of soverignty to the undemocratic organisation that is the EU.

    With the principle of "no taxation without representation", would it be appropriate to refuse to pay tax if the EU constitution comes into effect, if the Irish are succesfully railroaded into giving a yes vote in the upcoming 'referendum'.

    What other actions are justified or where should the line be drawn which should provoke civil disobedience?
  2. There is actually a little known part of the Treason Act that requires individuals in Britain to NOT pay tax to a government guilty of treason.
    The same Treason Act makes it absolutely clear that the Lisbon Treaty is treason.

    Therefor the long established law of this land requires that we all desist from paying tax to the current government. I'm sure a dozen or two posters will jump in and tell you this can't be true, if you aren't sure go and read the Treason Act.

    As for civil disobedience, my personal feelings are that once Parliament started to act in its own interests instead of the interests of the nation then that point has come.
    The moment Parliament introduced the smoking ban but excempt itself from that ban is when the rule of law and democracy in this country took a nosedive. Our politicians created one law for the public and another law for themselves. They lost all moral authority to govern from that point. Civil disobedience is long overdue. Don't hold your breath for it making any difference though.
    I have been considering this very point for quite some time now. My only reservations are about its effectiveness but it is certainly warranted.
  3. No need for civil disobedience. Undermining the happy constitution by which the Queen is sole fount of justice and there can be but one law, that of the Realm. It is treason. So just ask the Queen via the Lords for immediate remedy. When it is not forthcoming invoke the right of lawful rebellion till the Queen obeys her Coronation Oath and we quit Europe and return to one Law in our Realm only.

    Look up Brian Buxton (ex Royal Marine Commando) Head of the Popular Alliance Party.
  4. I put the linkie to a relevant Common Law Information site as an example of what we should do about James Shortt. It is on the Baron Castleshort 4 thread. The linkie to the silent majority type site.
  5. It depends on what is classed as civil disobedience, if a government has drafted and hurried new laws in to make the most innocent of actions classed as wrong under laws, I mean who would consider taking a photograph a terrorist act?
    Passive demonstrations I feel are a right, not the rent a mob type that the press seem to manage to find, but the type that Ghandi used, it is disobedient but it does not go towards the violent type of march..
    As for the question of no taxation without representtation towards the EU I would like to agree with you, it is pushing through too much too fast without thinking of the consequences, however there are many EU countries that do not take all of the EU dictats on, unlike us, and no I am not a total anti european, as a common market it was fine as a Union it will not work.
    The only Eu that could work is, Britain in charge, France catering, Italy Wines member, Germany planning and road building
  6. Like aunching us into at least one deeply unwise war, buggering about with habeas corpus, installing CCTV up everyone's Jacksie, filching expenses while deficit spending like a crack whore, giving The City a deregulated license to steal pensions and then bailing the bunglers with your grand kids taxes. The disorders appear to be systemic and largely a product of a national governed by a class of folk that don't give a toss about its people. Plenty to riot about quite apart from the burghers of Brussels meddling with your sacred sausage.
  7. "When Injustice Becomes Law Resistance Becomes Duty" - Adam Kokesh
  8. There are a number of Treason Acts the elements of most of them have been repealed. Thus, we have the Treason Acts of 1351, 1695, 1708, 1795 (repealed), 1814, 1817, 1842 and Treason Felony Act 1845.

    Nowhere in any element of the above Acts which survive at law is there any authority for the contention you claim.

    Source: Westlaw/Lexis/Nexis
  9. do you have any suggestions then iolis? if there are any relevant laws, it may be useful.

    I would think any civil disobedience would need to be massive for it to have the desired effect. if only a few stop paying tax for example, it is easy for the state to make an example of them. if thousands do it ....
  10. Civil disobedience would result in the Army being deployed to counter it. Don't really want that do we!!
  11. do we really want to live in an undomocratic state, under the heel of the EU with little of no choice in the laws we are subject to?

    As i say, a basic, perhaps most fundamental principle of democracy, is;

    "No taxation without representation!"

    Maybe I should take a trip to see a legal type person to decern the options.

    Perhaps it would be better to start a campaign;

    If the lisbon treaty comes into effect, we will refuse to pay tax!
  12. Okay, I'll phone Glasgow tomorrow and tell then not to deduct my tax from now on
  13. You do get representation, every 5 years (maximum) we all get to choose who we want to run the goverment.
  14. Think about all the overtime you would be picking up, just like the plod picked up during the destruction of our mining industry. Fix bayonets. Advance. No prisoners. They are only tax paying scum afterall.
  15. When the bloody hell do the army get overtime? Have I been missing out on it all these years?