Van Crevelds Latest: GWOT V The Troubles

Discussion in 'Current Affairs, News and Analysis' started by alib, Apr 29, 2007.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. Bill Lind quotes the Israeli military theorist Martin Van Creveld's latest book:
    I can't imagine a time when that type of cold blooded math will interest the Pentagon.

    The British modestly called their other victorious little war The Malayan Emergency. The Global War On Terror always was a over blown piece of rhetoric for what should have been sold as series of police actions. Now there is wearying talk in the US of The Long War evidence of draining will rather than dogged determination of say PIRA who called The Troubles just that as they slowly filled up Milltown cemetary and touted each other out until the Long Peace arrived.

    Some foolish Likudniks like Charles Krauthammer want to style current nastiness as WWIV. That eagerness to escalate has brought us within a couple of years of WWIII in the Persian Gulf.
  2. My bold - other makes it sound like the only one we had. We had lots of vicious little wars -
  3. Stonker

    Stonker On ROPs

    We had military victory over the PIRA as early as 1972, if not before.

    Yet still they came back, and gnawed at us; civilians and soldiers alike.

    We did not, in the end "defeat" Republicanism. We (soldiers and police) managed its violence, until politicians - whether through inspiration and intelligence, or by blundering and good luck matters not - brought the various parties to a pont where "The Struggle" (seen in the light of an economically resurgent, secular Irish Republic, which had renounced claims on the 6 counties, where big investment ££ was beginning to arrive, while the Ecstasy generation - in its loved-up state of mind - spotted that paramilitaries selling drugs were just gangsters, and not romantic) simply ceased to be relevant.

    In 1995, I wrote to the USA Parameters mag, a response to a piece they had published, praising the new improved manual for Operations Other Than War (US FM 100-11 IIRC, I prob'ly misremember the serial no).

    The FM was based on the Powell doctrine of "Victory Through Overwhelming Force" - in every circumstance.

    I asked them to imagine how that might have played out in Ulster. Wondered what "Victory" would look like in Ulster.

    It was not published.

    But, with or without Petraeus, a decade on, the US, its President and many of its Generals will insist on "Victory" in the "GWOT".

    Fuckwits, all of them.