Trident and an Independent Scotland

Discussion in 'Current Affairs, News and Analysis' started by AndyPipkin, Jan 8, 2012.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. On the contrary, we might need them all the more - to defend English soil from rampaging Picts.
  2. Well **** me ol' boots, whydoncha? We haven't had thread with so much potential for anti-Scots bile for....oh, for at least a week?
  3. So they'd have to replace DM Glen Douglas and allocate a new port, not the end of the world.

    There are plenty of alternative sites and I'm sure many areas of England or Wales would gladly accept the investment associated with creating an alternative.

  4. Nothing anti-Scots from me Biscuits.

    I mate hate that cnut Salmond (no surprise there, he's a politician) but I firmly believe in the Union between Scotland and England.
  5. Yes, I for one can't wait to have a feck load of nukes dumped on my doorstep and become a prime target for every potential enemy's nukes.
  6. Sovereign English Area (SEA) Faslane and Coulport?
  7. They could always be parked near London. That's where the investment usually goes, after all... :wink:
    • Like Like x 3

  8. Nice one! Tell us another.

    No chance. Disband the army and replace with weekend pikemen? Possible. Sink the navy and get a few armed coppers to do circuits of the coast in pedaloes? Could happen. Air force done away with and tramps paid to run kites with hand grenades taped to them around strategic locations? Not out of the question.

    But abandon nukes? Never. At least not until photon torpedoes become the weapon of choice.

    Nukes are not weapons. They are political poker chips. Conversely in order for them to be of value they have to be militarily credible. The more credible the higher the value.

    The last weapon system in the possession of her Maj. will be of the unscheduled sunrise variety.
    • Like Like x 4
  9. Did the fact that these particular nukes are on a submarine platform and therefore deployed to pre-determined positions at time of conflict pass you by?
  10. An English enclave, that's exactly what I was thinking. Income (and other) taxes paid in accordance with the rules set by Westminster, not Holyrood, and circumventing the Scottish Treasury.

  11. Cor blimey, luvvaduck! Look what you've gorn an' dahn nah, eh? You've tak'n the rug from aht under their feet!
  12. Except that our nuke boats would probably go to an area that would already be a likely nuclear target anyway IF we ever actually faced nuclear war. If we ever faced a real nuclear stand-off against a real nuclear opponent again then chances are that most people have a few nuclear targets within fallout distance of their house. I think there were something like 8 or 9 within twenty miles of where I grew up as a kid (on Merseyside).
  13. Well - if the issue is an independent Scotland, it would depend on whether they remained allied to the remains of the UK on defence or wanted their own Army and Navy. If they remain, no change, if they split, the hiving off the Scottish regiments would be easy, less so other Army elements and the other Forces. I guess sub bases would have to move south, with all the consequent loss of employment.

    I think it comes down to whether you seriously believe we might ever have to use British Forces to defend British soil. For nigh on half a century, we've had a backstop of nuclear deterrence that made it pretty unthinkable that anyone would invade. Even at the height of the cold war, we had the comfort of knowing that if Ivan started rolling across the North German plain, we could go nuclear, and that thought perhaps prevented it from happening.

    But my Dad, for one, looks at things differently - he remembers the threat of invasion here in 1940, the Russians rolling into Hungary in '56 and Prague in '68. Who is to say that oil and gas funded Russians won't one day fancy controlling more of the UK than the odd Premiership club? That the Germans and French won't lose patience with our negative attitude to Europe and stage a little coup backed by Euro troops? The Americans are set to cut back on their defence commitments to Europe, and if it came to a shooting war, I wouldn't want to be reliant on French assets to defend these islands, so whether Scotland goes its own way or not, we need armed forces capable of deterring would be opponents.
    • Like Like x 1
  14. OT - but are you sure all those F&C 'Jocks' will want to join the 'Scottish Army'?