TRFs, Bde Flashes, Qual Badges! Did I join the Boy Scouts?

Discussion in 'Officers' started by PCLG, Aug 29, 2005.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. The amount of badges now being worn in service is ridiculous.

    Example: Rank, Bde Flash, Corp TRF, Cdo Qual Badge, Para Qual Badge, DZ Flash, PTI Qual Badge.

    I was under the impression that when deploying on Operations only Rank insignia was to be worn for OPSEC. Do we now disregard this?

    I have been told that the TRF is partly there to improve espirit d'corps!! If a one inch by two inch piece of material can improve morale that much I think we have some more serious and urgent issues to resolve.

    At what point did OPSEC become a trivial issue?
  2. I remeber that Regimental SOPs dictated that anyone Para trained had to wear wings, the only time that I witnessed anything contary to this was in Bosnia when 23 PFA were out there and this was only "observed" notionally. Considering SF ops you can understand the reasoning behind this arguement but for a normal working unit? Look back through any literature of Airborne operations in WW2 and all manner of badges are worn and rightly so.

    A better question would be when did OPSEC become so fashionable and why?
  3. An officer PTI. Would that be someone from the Small Arms Thingummy Corps?

  4. In BAOR during the Cold War OPSEC was taken very seriously by the British at least! Apart from Berlin Brigade which wore a Patch as part of the Post War agreement with Russia, The USA, and France to identify troops. Hardly any unit patches were worn from the 1960's and the change over from Battle Dress to Green Combats.
  5. The example wasn't an Offr.
  6. One further point to this discussion is cap badges and berets. Cap bages give the biggest clues to a units role. In the case of berets, we know some denote a specialist unit, Airborne, Commando and Smurfs. Why wear them if OPSEC is of such high importance? The British Army is the fastest to adopt the soft approach (no helmet) in operations, how much does that give away about unit capabilities and deployed assets? Although I don't agree to the US method of boy scout badges, I do believe they have their own relevance.
  7. Perhaps a better way would be to wear just the simple black & OG slide to denote rank, the small union flag on the left arm to denote nationality, and on the right arm a shoulder title by the shoulder seam, the curved wool type as was worn in the Second world war. The RM and RE have them, they can be discreet for Opsec if you wish and it would make more sense than trying to figure out what a particular arrangement of coloured bars means!
  8. ....or maybe a Master at Arms in the APTC?

    Just an idea.....

  9. Yes but surely they do not wear a badge; that's not something a chap would do.

  10. True on cap badges. Remember though for the US, they don't really have special cap badges, so 'boy scout' badges are their alternative.
  11. Spam officers have their branch insignia, e.g. Infantry- crossed rifles (AKA 'Idiot Sticks'), Engineers- castle, SF- crossed arrows, on their left collar. Not sure that their look is the way forward though- medals for completing training etc., multiple unit patches (current unit and unit you have previously seen combat with etc.) or, my personal favourite, the bloused trousers in jump boots even when in dress uniform if you're Spam airborne. :roll: Their costumes are far too busy. You don't want to have to walk around looking like you're El Presidente of the People's Republic of Monganita.
  12. Canadians did that as well (at least the Ab Regt)
  13. I knew they did something to deserve getting disbanded...
  14. A few thoughts on OPSEC.

    1. The current, and very possibly future enemy of choice is the third world insurgent from a failed state. He doesn't care whether you are a para-trained cavalryman or a corporal in the AGC. He just wants to kill you and doesn't give a toss about the ORBAT like Ivan did. Also if he really wants to know what your operational capability is all he needs to...

    2. switch on the BBC/ CNN/ Sky/ Fox etc. There he will see embedded journos giving out open-source real-time intelligence that his Cold War counterpart would only dream of. In the modern information battlespace OPSEC is the fly in the Media Ops ointment is it not? The BBC could work to your advantage, though, as Johnny Insurgent will always assume that the entire British Army is broken down, rudderless and about to retreat.

    3. If our insurgent doesn't have a TV he can rely on the Worldwide Web and find reams of open-source info from MoD websites about the precise composition of the British army down to platoon level.

    As I have posted before I was in green at a time when an ACE Mobile Force flash was skin to a Victorian lady showing her ankle, let alone the jamboree-bag of flashes and goodies the modern army wears. It reminded me of watching UKSF personnel on the TV a few years back evacuating British nationals from some godforsaken country and showing out immediately because they were wearing completely plain combat gear with no badges whatsoever.

    So, don't get captured with no insignia; Johnny Insurgent will immediately assume that you are SF and get the special car-battery kit out for you.

  15. cpunk

    cpunk LE Moderator

    Further to this, as anyone who has ever been involved in doling out interrogation and TQ training will tell you, UKSF personnel can be recognised a mile off for a whole host of straightforward reasons. Top advice is to wear bog standard issue kit, rank insignia and keep your/an RLC beret in your pocket, and if you are SF, then eschew that super gore-tex, ventile, kevlar, multi-pocket ultrasmock, in favour of something in DPM rip-stop from 'Man at Q&M'.