Theory on tanks withdrawal from Iraq - rubbish?

Discussion in 'RAC' started by hansvonhealing, Sep 24, 2006.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. I'm no Tankie, so what do you think of this theory? Is it rubbish?

    Why Did the British Really Withdraw Their Tanks?

    by paradox
    Last week came news the British contingent in Iraq was immediately withdrawing all of it heavy Challenger battle tanks. At the time speculation was that utility of the machines, each weighing 125,000 pounds, were useless in guerilla tactics that demanded light speed.

    That speculation may have been off base. The British aren’t getting the tanks out now because they’re not much use (believe me, no field commander wants to give an armored, mobile 120 mm rifled gun), but because now may be the only time they can get them out at all.

    There is an absurd, alarming presumption in the United States that withdrawal from the Iraqi theatre will be as seamless and easy as invasion. Nothing could be further from the truth.

    One day, in one glorious episode of reason and sanity, US forces will leave Iraq. The sooner they do so the more orderly and safer it will be. Every day wasted in not withdrawing notches up the likelihood that US forces will flee in a desperate situation where there are no good choices.

    Tanks cannot be flown out the country, and the northern route to NATO ally Turkey through the mountains is likely impassable. That means two potential routes south along either the Tigris or Euphrates rivers to get back to Kuwait.

    If the Unites States were facing an organized guerrilla movement instead of the mishmash of civil war our casualty county would be a lot higher, and if this situation changes US forces could be enormously vulnerable upon withdrawal. There are innumerable vulnerable choke points along both southern routes, and a determined enemy could turn a US withdrawal in to flaming, exploding rout.

    F-15’s and A10’s can’t unclog a road or fix a blasted bridge. The British know it and may have gotten out their tanks while they still can.

    http://www.theleftcoaster.com/archives/008828.php
     
  2. Again no Tankie but didn't the US fly 3 abrahams into the North of Iraq during the invasion on their c17s?

    My limited knowledge is that the c17s can take an MBT.
     
  3. Challengers weigh how much?
    If the US withdraws a determined enemy....
    With no air cover?

    As you say, rubbish.

    To be more precise, total bowlocks.

    Man's a buffoon.

    Next
     
  4. They flew a company in. I think it was fifteen tanks, and a recovery vehicle.

    NTM
     
  5. For the British to remove their CR2 they simply take them from Basrah to Umm Qasr and ship them out.
     
  6. The man is talking turd. total utter turd