Tanks to get Star Wars defence shield

Sixty

ADC
Moderator
Book Reviewer
#3
Telegraph website editor: Quick, get me a photograph of a tank to illustrate this page.

Hapless admin monkey: Here you go boss.

The Daily Telegraph said:
Tanks = CVR(T)
 
#4
First time I've heard of repelling incoming rounds with the electromagnetic idea, they were banging on about electric fields that would vapourise the liquid metal in a shaped charge type weapon a few years ago though.

The idea of a force-field, and how cool it is, totally eclipses any questions as to how much we actually need this technology, however.
 
#6
Sounds like a great idea... make a tank's bullet-proof-ness dependant on everything working correctly.

What happened every single episode of Star Trek, right between Kirk laying the alien bird and the "open fire all guns" moment?...

"Captain... sheilds are down."

Whilst it might make a handy addition to existing armour, I can't help but suspect that somewhere along the line some bright spark will say, "hey with the new system, we can afford to strip out a little of the conventional armour."
 
#7
Will cavalry officers also get light sabres?
 
#8
Rantallion said:
Sounds like a great idea... make a tank's bullet-proof-ness dependant on everything working correctly.

What happened every single episode of Star Trek, right between Kirk laying the alien bird and the "open fire all guns" moment?...

"Captain... sheilds are down."

Whilst it might make a handy addition to existing armour, I can't help but suspect that somewhere along the line some bright spark will say, "hey with the new system, we can afford to strip out a little of the conventional armour."
If you read the link that's exactly what they want to do.
 
#10
it is possible to incorporate material known as supercapacitors
Interesting to see that this work has finally been declassified. I was closely involved in the supercapacitor project in the early days.

The scientist leading the project was fairly well known in the 80s. Here is a rare photo of him from that time:-





The initial experiments were downright dangerous. No health and safety back then, as you can see from this photo of me and one of the boffins.

 
#11
Ancient_Mariner said:
it is possible to incorporate material known as supercapacitors
Interesting to see that this work has finally been declassified. I was closely involved in the supercapacitor project in the early days.

The scientist leading the project was fairly well known in the 80s. Here is a rare photo of him from that time:-





The initial experiments were downright dangerous. No health and safety back then, as you can see from this photo of me and one of the boffins.

Can we assume that you ended up stuck in 1885 and had to return to the present the hard way? :D
 
#12
jaybee2786 said:
mistersoft said:
Will cavalry officers also get light sabres?
Why are the ones they have already, too heavy for them.
Probably but they don't like to complain about it.
 
#13
This old news -

I've been able to create a repelling force shield around me for decades, in enemy territory it's known as an SBD or in blue on blue incidents as a "Jeeezuss, who the fuck dropped THAT ?"
 
#14
To read some comments, one wonders if some people think that we shouldn't make all our tanks out of nothing but face-hardened steel.

Yes, the electric armour may not be 100% reliable, but neither is bar armour, ERA or many other systems. You'll note that currently many of these systems are added on to light and medium platforms in order to improve their protection without compromising their mobility too much.
 
#15
parapauk said:
Can we assume that you ended up stuck in 1885 and had to return to the present the hard way? :D
I tried returning to the 21st century but I didn't like it so I'm now back in 1885 and posting this through a wormhole in the space/time continuum.

I like it better in 1885. Karl Marx only died 2 years ago and I haven't sobered up yet. Flogging and the rum ration are still going strong and the only women aboard HM Ships are prostitutes.

Advocates of votes for women are burned at the stake; we still have the easy to use old money - florins, half crowns, tanners, white fivers, ten bob notes etc you know where you are with 240 pence to the pound.

No easyJet in 1885 so European travel is still an adventure. I was recently in Austria where I got, ahem, friendly with Klara, one of the chambermaids at the inn where I was staying. She's married to the local customs bloke so we had to keep it discreet and I hear she's now up the duff.

To cut a long story short, I think I might be Adolf Hitler's dad.

Apart from that, and smallpox, everything here is fine.

Edited to add :-

I met a very interesting bloke called Hollerith. He has some strange ideas about punch card machines. I invested some cash so he could start a company. He's thinking of calling it International Business Machines.
 
#16
ouyin said:
Rantallion said:
Sounds like a great idea... make a tank's bullet-proof-ness dependant on everything working correctly.

What happened every single episode of Star Trek, right between Kirk laying the alien bird and the "open fire all guns" moment?...

"Captain... sheilds are down."

Whilst it might make a handy addition to existing armour, I can't help but suspect that somewhere along the line some bright spark will say, "hey with the new system, we can afford to strip out a little of the conventional armour."
If you read the link that's exactly what they want to do.
I did read the link, I just didn't read the article.
 
#17
What a rubbish article, this armour was only ever intended for trucks etc where extra weight is not an option. It's only effective against single impulse warheads anyway. My understanding of the initiator is a fibre optic mesh which triggers the discharge when something penetrates and breaks the light circuit, not "Sophisticated tracking systems". Perhaps the author has got confused with the Israeli hyperbole surrounding their Trophy system? Might actually be an idea to develop, or buy, an active kill system for the few Challenger to survive the next cuts, since they will be a precious commodity?
More guff about Super Bainite armour; it's conventional armour made cheaply-not perforated armour as the article suggests-although you can make perforated OUT of it.
 
#18
ERA is only effective against single warheads, bar armour is only effective against RPG7s.
 
#19
incendiarycutlery said:
ERA is only effective against single warheads, bar armour is only effective against RPG7s.
I'm aware of that however the article claims;
Although it would last for only a fraction of a second, if timed correctly it could prevent rocket propelled grenades, which detonate on impact, from reaching their target. The supercapacitor could then be rapidly recharged ready for another attack.
I think it's a great idea but hardly a Star Wars shield and I don't see it being deployed on anything other than light vehicles.
 
#20
How about on areas of heavier vehicles that are protected with lesser armour, such as the roof, but are increasingly vulnerable to top attack either from new weapons or conventional weapons in urban environment.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
FBW The Training Wing 0
Porridge_gun Aviation 8
PartTimePongo Current Affairs, News and Analysis 4

Similar threads

Latest Threads

Top