Six Nations 2018

Helm

MIA
Moderator
Book Reviewer
Given the score was 12-0 at the time of the "try" surely the final score would have been 12-7 (given the conversion was made) as the penalty would not have been given so no 3 pts, the penalty in the second half would not have been given either as the circumstances that led to it would no have occurred.
We can be generous and throw that in we still end up winning
 
Except of course the one penalty was instead of the"try" which is the mistake our little Welshonian friend has made
Yes, correct. I'd thought it was brought back for a scrum which England collapsed giving Wales the penalty but it wasn't. The try was disallowed but Wales got a penalty instead so wouldn't have had both scores.
Not that I've moaned about the try disallowed, though, that was someone else. Once a decision is made, it's made.
 
Just my opinion, and of course I'm English, but I think the TMO was spot on. To score you need downward pressure and all I can see is a Welsh hand alongside the ball.
 
It's starting to sound as though you don't beat Wales, just score more points.
 

Similar threads


Latest Threads

Top