Sacking Slim

[jonwilly]

Bill Slim who was, in my opinion the finest commander of troops during WW II was Sacked twice in his time as a GOC.
First by Irwin who had the decency to send Slim a signal saying ' Not you Sacked but me' when Wavell sacked Irwin, and then after the jap was all but out of Burma by Leese.
Leese seems to have been on extreamly weak ground.
The books I have read leave me wondering just as to why, as they choose to be er 'Vauge' on the details.
john

 

[gennithmedic]

Because Slim wasn't a slack jawed loser, I guess. Common too- teacher and that...

 

[Outstanding]

Maybe because he told the truth, - simply not done!!

 

[Archimedes]

To be fair to Leese, Ronald Lewin puts this down to c*ck up rather than any deep conspiracy; Robert Lyman is less kind but suggests that Leese felt he needed someone with whom he had a better personal relationship. Either way, Leese's basic premise was that Slim needed a rest and that his lack of expertise in amphibious ops would put him at a disadvantage for Op Zipper, suggesting a change in command arrangements.

Leese proposed to Mountbatten that when XIIth Army formed, with the task of mopping up in Burma, XIVth Army went on to conduct Zipper. Slim would move to XIIth Army. XIVth Army would go to Philip Christison.

Mountbatten thought otherwise, and suggested that resting Slim and making a temporary appointment to XIVth Army would be a better bet.

Leese was to approach Slim, sound him out about having a rest and moving to XIIth Army, but on no account was he to do anything that was contrary to Slim's wishes. If Slim wanted to stay with XIVth Army, then that - as far as Mountbatten was concerned - was that.

Sadly, Leese told Christison (who was a friend) he was to take XIVth Army *before* he spoke to Slim and gave Christison the impression that Slim was going on indefinite leave and not taking any future command. One of Leese's most tactless staff officers went to see Slim and gave Slim the impression he was being sacked; Slim insisted that if the C-in-C Land forces in SEA was getting rid of him, he should at least have the decency to do so himself.

Leese then saw Slim and Lewin suggests he then compounded the comms c*ck up by confirming Slim's impression that he was to hand over command of XIVth Army and take on XIIth Army after some leave, rather than simply sounding him out about the idea which was all Mountbatten would let Leese to do - his plan, I suspect being that Slim would say 'er, not happy about that idea, sir', whereupon Leese would say 'He doesn't like the idea, sir', to which Mountbatten would say 'told you so; give him some proper leave and tell him to be back on such-and-such a date'

Slim thus thought that he'd been sacked from XIVth Army, and told Leese that he thought that as it seemed he'd lost the confidence of commander land forces, it would be better if he didn't take XIIth Army and instead retired. Slim then told his wife and staff he'd been fired, while Leese only slowly began to appreciate that he'd handled it badly, while the XIVth Army staff were aghast to the point that Slim apparently had to dissuade several of them from resigning (Lewin suggest that one of the senior RAF officers also had to be persuaded not to resign).

Full appreciation seems to have arrived only when Brooke sent a missive best summarised as 'What the Fcuk is going on, Dickie?' to Mountbatten.

Once that arrived, Leese was effectively done for. Slim was told he was to go on holiday - which was what Mountbatten had wanted Leese to sort out for him in the first place - while Christison would take temporary command of XIVth Army, and Stopford would take XIIth Army. Slim's holiday (taken back in Britain) concluded with him being informed that Leese had been sacked and he was to replace him.

Three answers therefore suggest themselves. First, that Leese was desperate to replace Slim and sought to ease him out with the offer of a good rest and then a new command, in the hope that he'd agree to go. Mountbatten would be faced with a situation where Slim had agreed to Leese's general premise, leaving Mountbatten without room to manoeuvre.

Second, that Leese simply made a complete horlicks of carrying out Mountbatten's instructions and gave Slim completely the wrong impression, again with disastrous effect on Leese's career.

Third, that Leese deliberately disobeyed orders, told Slim he was to take XIIth Army with the notion that Slim would obey this instruction without demur, whereupon Leese would tell Mountbatten that after sounding him out, Slim had agreed to go. Mountbatten then believes Slim has agreed to go, rather than having obeyed orders to accept being pushed sideways.

Personally, I suspect that you have a mix of one and two above - Leese's over-eagerness to move Slim foundering when his skills at persuasion failed disastrously, creating a situation that he hadn't quite intended and didn't know how to deal with.

 

[Themanwho]

Nicely put, Archimedes, there's a more long winded and less succinct version of this in "Slim the Standard Bearer"(Cassel Books)

 

[jonwilly]

Last night I managed to have a drink in the local with our 87 year old veteran of Burma 42-45.
Knowing he was back in town I had with me a copy of 'Slim Master of War' to loan him.
After he said that he had not read this newish book I mentioned there was a piece at the end on Slims sacking and that was after Slim had reconqured Burma.
He chuckeld and said 'You know that was not the first time Bill Slim was sacked, Irwin chopped him after the Arakan fiasco, but then had the decency to send a signal saying "Not you sacked but me" '
He was having a good laugh and then he said apart from the first few months 'I was lucky to have Slim as my overall commander for my time in Burma.'
I asked about use of Flame throwers on bunkers, for he is an old sapper and he said that during his time in the Arakan and he was there to the end of that campain, he never saw a flame thrower, tho he knew they where employed during the advance down the Irrawaddy.
He stated that bunkers where normally taken out by a team of of say 4-5 under command of a junior officer using satchel charges. Normally suicide missions but never a shortage of volanteers.
john

 

[Mr_Relaxed]

Have just read 'Slim Master of War' which I thought was a cracking read, although a little too much on the hero-worship. Unfortunately I find that style leads me to wonder if the biographer is glossing over other things. A minor quibble however.

Somer interesting background to Wingate as well, and makes me want to read more about China's involvement.

With Slim, it shows that when the CoC works, it really does work, especially when those in charge actually do their own job, and let their subordinate do his.

The other thing I do notice is that with every biography I read of any British WW2 commander, I find my regard for Winston Churchill lowering, which is a shame. Parallels with the modern age, when politicians insist that something be done, even if that means trouble further down the military track. Does no one read Sun Tzu?

 

[Themanwho]

The other thing I do notice is that with every biography I read of any British WW2 commander, I find my regard for Winston Churchill lowering, which is a shame. Parallels with the modern age, when politicians insist that something be done, even if that means trouble further down the military track. Does no one read Sun Tzu?

If you wish to reinvigourate your regard for Winston, I recommend reading AlanBrooke's comments on him. All of them, not the cherry-picked bon mots which are used to promote one view. From Brooke's war diaries, many of Churchill's faults were exposed by the man who was his almost constant companion throught the war years. In his view, these faults were easily outweighed by his qualities.

Churchill was a bullying, interfering, easily distracted romantic without whom we would have lost the war. No one would claim he was perfect, but he was the man who led this country through its darkest hour to ultimate victory , in a way no present politico could dream of doing.