'Rogue' US soldier kills Afghans

#1
'Rogue' US soldier kills Afghans

A US soldier in Afghanistan has killed 10 civilians and wounded five in Kandahar province after suffering a breakdown, officials say.

12 month tours are not a good idea. Discuss....
 

Bouillabaisse

LE
Book Reviewer
#3
'Rogue' US soldier kills Afghans

A US soldier in Afghanistan has killed 10 civilians and wounded five in Kandahar province after suffering a breakdown, officials say.

12 month tours are not a good idea. Discuss....
Kneejerk reactions are not a good idea. Discuss...

How many people have deployed on 12 month tours in Iraq and Afghanistan? I don't know but I'd hazard that with repeat tours it's over a million. How many have had a breakdown and gone postal? One.
 
#4
Kneejerk reactions are not a good idea. Discuss...

How many people have deployed on 12 month tours in Iraq and Afghanistan? I don't know but I'd hazard that with repeat tours it's over a million. How many have had a breakdown and gone postal? One.
Shooting civvies is a bit of a knee jerk, I'll give you that. But it's a few more than one. Do a search and you'll find all sorts (people throwing grenades into HQ tents etc).

I think it's a tricky balance. 12 months gets better continuity & engagement with locals etc. that said, I came back from my last 6 monther (8 really when you include all the PDT) feeling utterly ball bagged.
 
#5
'Rogue' US soldier kills Afghans

A US soldier in Afghanistan has killed 10 civilians and wounded five in Kandahar province after suffering a breakdown, officials say.

12 month tours are not a good idea. Discuss....
Agreed. 6 month tours remove the problem completely. If we were to switch to the 12 month model, I can only assume we'd have blokes getting mashed on vodka and bayoneting kids and whatnot.
 
#8
#9
'Rogue' US soldier kills Afghans

A US soldier in Afghanistan has killed 10 civilians and wounded five in Kandahar province after suffering a breakdown, officials say.

12 month tours are not a good idea. Discuss....
It's not too bad, at least he didn't burn any Korans.
 
#10
It's not too bad, at least he didn't burn any Korans.

Still won't go down well. Afghans will be outraged that an American soldier killed innocent Afghan women and children; that job should be done by their own countrymen/families.

"They come over here, taking our murders..."
 
#12
Still won't go down well. Afghans will be outraged that an American soldier killed innocent Afghan women and children; that job should be done by their own countrymen/families.

"They come over here, taking our murders..."
Bit harsh mate!

Have to wonder about the Seppo's though.
 
#13
BBC News - US soldier kills Afghan civilians in Kandahar

According to the Beeb he's a Staff Sergeant. Wandered off at 3am and opened up in some houses. Could be 17 dead, including women and children. I expect there'll be a bunch of angry rioting Afghans adding to the pile already pissed off about that book burning thing.
Well if they killed any boys they might.Just women and girls probably don't care.
 
#16
Where is Afghan_candynackers when we need him.
 
#20

Similar threads

New Posts

Top