• ARRSE have partnered with Armadillo Merino to bring you an ARRSE exclusive, generous discount offer on their full price range.
    To keep you warm with the best of Merino gear, visit www.armadillomerino.co.uk and use the code: NEWARRSE40 at the checkout to get 40% off!
    This superb deal has been generously offered to us by Armadillo Merino and is valid until midnight on the the 28th of February.

Portrayal of a soldier with PTSD on Coronation Street

#1
How on earth do the Coronation Street writers and producers expect us to believe or sympathise with the character Dean Windass and in particular his portrayal of an Afghanistan veteran with PTSD?

He has supposedly been blown up on his first tour of Afghanistan and seen a close friend killed in the subsquent fire fight right before his very eyes. A friend, I might add, that had saved him during the initial blast.

Now all of this I am not disputing. What I do find highly unbelievable is that fact he ever joined the army in the first place. This is mainly due to the lack him dropping in key phrases when he talks in everyday conversation. Phrases like: "Happy Days", "Squared away", "Scoff was shit" and "I'd smash that bird in a wheelchair back doors in big style" or by the fact he fails to utter a single civvy-confusing Army abbreviation.

A strongly worded letter to Points Of View is on it's way I tell thee.
 

the_boy_syrup

LE
Book Reviewer
#3
He has supposedly been blown up on his first tour of Afghanistan and seen a close friend killed in the subsquent fire fight right before his very eyes. A friend, I might add, that had saved him during the initial blast.

.
That all happened in about 3 weks just after he went AWOL also
Would he not be better served returning to his unit and getting help than hiding under the stairs?
Plus none of his army mates discuss the smell of piss or twiglets round him or call him gwar
 
#7
How on earth do the Coronation Street writers and producers expect us to believe or sympathise with the character Dean Windass and in particular his portrayal of an Afghanistan veteran with PTSD?

He has supposedly been blown up on his first tour of Afghanistan and seen a close friend killed in the subsquent fire fight right before his very eyes. A friend, I might add, that had saved him during the initial blast.

Now all of this I am not disputing. What I do find highly unbelievable is that fact he ever joined the army in the first place. This is mainly due to the lack him dropping in key phrases when he talks in everyday conversation. Phrases like: "Happy Days", "Squared away", "Scoff was shit" and "I'd smash that bird in a wheelchair back doors in big style" or by the fact he fails to utter a single civvy-confusing Army abbreviation.

A strongly worded letter to Points Of View is on it's way I tell thee.
The episode where you see a picture of him with his parents wearing C95's with the buttons done all the way to the top with capbadge sitting squarely in the middle of his forhead had me shouting at the TV.

Further to this the episode where a Captain visits during Gary's AWOL with the beret ribbon hanging down the back of his head had me fuming. Seriously how hard would it have been for the writers to visit the nearest TA centre or something and get some proper advice.

His 'unit' obvoiusly skipped the health and hygene part on shaving too.

Also listening to his account on last nights episode made him sound like his character was a loggie further adding to my general embarressment.

I was all for this storyline at first but all it's doing now is making the Army look like a bag of shit!
 
#8
Guys, FFS get a grip will ya. ITS A FKUKIN SOAP, and a shite one at that. Who cares if some bone soap writers/continuity knobbers can't get their facts right. Do you not remember that homage to HMF Soldier/Soldier, which was also a load of shite and full of mistakes. WHO CARES :omfg:
 
#9
Guys, FFS get a grip will ya. ITS A FKUKIN SOAP, and a shite one at that. Who cares if some bone soap writers/continuity knobbers can't get their facts right. Do you not remember that homage to HMF Soldier/Soldier, which was also a load of shite and full of mistakes. WHO CARES :omfg:
Its not real!!? Bastards.

I spent a fortune on flowers and teddy bears when that train fell out of the sky.

(I'd better cancel my trip to Manchester to hunt down those two young lezzers as well I suppose)
 
#10
Its not real!!? Bastards.

I spent a fortune on flowers and teddy bears when that train fell out of the sky.

(I'd better cancel my trip to Manchester to hunt down those two young lezzers as well I suppose)
Yes as they are in my cellar and I dont live there.

If Corry isn't real, sorry to the parents of two missing lezzers from Mancland. You can have them back in about 5 years.
 
#11
Sad bunch of fukkers, the only time I watched the street was in early 80s Germany. It was shit then but at least it was in english.
East enders with Dirty Den was a breath of fresh air.
 
#12
Corrie must be full of PTSD cases after the train jumped off the embankment and ploughed down the street for a pint in the Rovers... killing off a few pesky characters in the bargain. Did it total those gopping houses across the road from the Rovers, where Mike Baldwins knicker factory used to be?
 
#15
Just been talking to the woman next to me about this thread who watches it religiously. She says the army lad has been sat in his shed since christmas which raises the question.....Has the Iron Duke been giving them advice?
 

jim24

LE
Book Reviewer
#16
Bring back Eddie Yeats. IS the cat still on the roof in the credits. These are the only two things which matter.
Oh and lesbian prisoners in dungeons. Put that on.
I met Eddie at the Boat Show once turned out he was really a posh yacht lovrer called "Geoffrey"
 

jarrod248

LE
Gallery Guru
#17
I gave advice on a coronation St story but they altered it quite a bit to make it more dramatic but it wasn't realistic. I imagine they had some advice but it wasn't interesting enough.
 
#20
How on earth do the Coronation Street writers and producers expect us to believe or sympathise with the character Dean Windass and in particular his portrayal of an Afghanistan veteran with PTSD?

He has supposedly been blown up on his first tour of Afghanistan and seen a close friend killed in the subsquent fire fight right before his very eyes. A friend, I might add, that had saved him during the initial blast.

Now all of this I am not disputing. What I do find highly unbelievable is that fact he ever joined the army in the first place. This is mainly due to the lack him dropping in key phrases when he talks in everyday conversation. Phrases like: "Happy Days", "Squared away", "Scoff was shit" and "I'd smash that bird in a wheelchair back doors in big style" or by the fact he fails to utter a single civvy-confusing Army abbreviation.

A strongly worded letter to Points Of View is on it's way I tell thee.
It'a not real. Just shite... turn the fucking telly over.
 

Latest Threads