Now that Amanda Knox's appeal has been overturned....

#10
What I find most interesting about this case is the polarisation. The American Media Circus seems to have issued a collective gasp, and the headlines in some major U.S. news outlets speak for themselves:

"An Innocent Abroad" from the New York Times http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/06/10/an-innocent-abroad/ --> an oldie but a goodie. I am providing a link, because I find the comments section particularly enlightening.
"Amanda Knox's Slander Trial Moved to Florence" from ABC News
"She thought the nightmare was over" from New York Daily News
Even Salon, a magazine that I respect for its typically nuanced coverage, insights, and journalistic standards gives us this pathos-laden headline: "Amanda Knox: "painful" to have acquittal overturned, "confident" in truth"

My personal favourite though is this gem from Singapore-based AsiaOne News: "Amanda Knox back in the dock: 'she-devil' or girl-next-door?" http://news.asiaone.com/News/Latest+News/World/Story/A1Story20130326-411559.html
Definitely worth a read, as it's a treasure trove of adjectives that I never thought could be combined in one story: lascivious, demonic, slovenly, seductive, naive, demure, drug-fuelled, etc.

I know we Brits often think that our own media are an abyss of misinformation, but as a current ex-pat, I can assure you that I miss the objectivity of British reporting!






Posted from the ARRSE Mobile app (iOS or Android)
 
#12

BuggerAll

LE
Kit Reviewer
Book Reviewer
#13
As ever when plod (or is that il ploddi) fucks up it leads to reasonable doubt.

From what has been reported it appears that the Italian police were sufficiently incompetent that we'll probably never know whether they did it or not.

BTB whether she was sexually active or a nun is pretty irrelevant.


Posted from the ARRSE Mobile app (iOS or Android)
 
#14
As ever when plod (or is that il ploddi) fucks up it leads to reasonable doubt.

From what has been reported it appears that the Italian police were sufficiently incompetent that we'll probably never know whether they did it or not.

BTB whether she was sexually active or a nun is pretty irrelevant.


Posted from the ARRSE Mobile app (iOS or Android)
You are quite right, BuggerAll. Judging from a distance, the Italian police and special investigators did apparently make quite a mess of the investigation - from questionable interrogation techniques in the absence of a defence lawyer to contaminated DNA evidence. It is indeed doubtful that the truth will ever be known.

I disagree on the relevance of her sex life. It appears to have played a role in the crime, which is described as a sex-murder case, and thus it could be important to examine those aspects of her past. Sex and jealousy are powerful motivators as the number of crimes committed in their names proves.

For me, the most fascinating part is the immediate and unreflective assumption of many Americans that she must be innocent by virtue of being a pretty, young American woman, whilst many Brits immediately claim she is guilty, because the victim was a pretty, young British woman. The comments on many U.S. Web sites express utter astonishment that a court in a foreign country could even have jurisdiction in a case involving an American citizen.


Posted from the ARRSE Mobile app (iOS or Android)
 
#15
The comments on many U.S. Web sites express utter astonishment that a court in a foreign country could even have jurisdiction in a case involving an American citizen.
Does make me wonder if a mind reader doing a tour of the United States would be hearing "America, fuck yeah!" on a loop.

Then again I seem to remember a certain level of indignation here, rightly or wrongly, over the Louise Woodward case.

What I find really interesting is the potential for an extradition request and how it would be dealt with in Washington given the lop-sided extradition deal the last Labour government generously agreed on our behalf.
 
#18
The appeal has to be re-run, they could easily come up with the "unsafe" conclusion again.

In any event, it's clear from the statements emanating from the US that they won't wear extradition, nor do the Italians have any sort of grounds to demand it so.... It's a pretty moot point.
 
#20
Shit! Now the media circus will be in a feeding frenzy for months/years to come. There's presently a domestic murder trial in progress which is the sole topic of two hour-a-day "news" programs. It pleases me no end to say I cannot tolerate Nancy Grace nor Jane Velez whatshername (Mitchell?), so I cannot even remember the accused's name.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
schweik The NAAFI Bar 79
Auld-Yin Competitions 2
schweik The NAAFI Bar 46

Similar threads

Latest Threads

Top