No10 horrified by gung-ho US in Cuban nuclear missile crisis

Discussion in 'Military History and Militaria' started by Lancashire Hussar, Apr 3, 2006.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. Interesting reading fromtoday's Telegraph.

    No 10 horrified by gung-ho US in Cuban nuclear missile crisis
    By Ben Fenton
    (Filed: 03/04/2006)

    Downing Street was shocked to learn in 1962 that its American allies had been poised to start World War III over the Cuban missile crisis without consulting Britain, new papers reveal.

    So important did the prime minister, Harold Macmillan, consider a report from his intelligence chief in the days after President John F Kennedy faced down a Soviet nuclear threat in his backyard that he immediately sent a copy to the Queen.

    The warning from Maj Gen Sir Kenneth Strong, the director of the Joint Intelligence Bureau, on Nov 19 struck particularly hard because it was delivered before the real end of the crisis.

    Unknown to No 10, three days earlier the US navy had conducted an exercise in North Carolina that was a dry run for an invasion of Cuba because its communist leader, Fidel Castro, was showing signs of reneging on the deal to remove the missiles and Ilyushin IL28 bombers that had pulled the world back from the brink.

    Sir Kenneth, who had been Gen Dwight D Eisenhower's intelligence chief at the time of D-Day, had received detailed briefings on how the Kennedy administration was handling the crisis, probably from his friend John Alex McCone, the director of the CIA.

    The papers, released last week at the National Archives in Kew, show that the retired general told Mr Macmillan and Earl Home, the foreign secretary, just how serious the situation had become in the full heat of the crisis.

    A "note for the record" of the meeting reports his saying that President Kennedy "had concluded" before deciding to blockade shipping to Cuba that it would mean a likely Soviet attack on West Berlin.

    "The Americans were prepared to go it alone, either without consulting their allies or irrespective of what their allies said, had the Russians reacted against any action in Cuba by moving against Berlin," the note reads.

    "Gen Strong thought the American government were prepared for their action in Cuba to escalate into the nuclear. It seemed to him that the US administration were over-confident that they had pinpointed the position of all the main sites of inter-continental ballistic missiles in the Soviet Union and they hoped they would be able to take these out with a pre-emptive attack by their bombers."

    Mr Macmillan and Lord Home were horrified that their allies, who had appeared to consult them from the early stages of the crisis, were only paying lip-service to the idea.

    They worried that America was dangerously gung-ho about fighting a nuclear war, which the Pentagon assumed it could win.

    The crisis had begun in late September 1962 when the CIA learned that Soviet technicians were installing nuclear missiles on the northern coast of Cuba.

    U2 spy plane flights over the island in October confirmed the presence of the missiles and on the 22nd of that month, as behind-the-scenes threats and demands were exchanged by Washington and Moscow, President Kennedy went on television to reveal that the world was on the brink of war. Nobody doubted that it would be a nuclear conflict.

    After six days of stand-off as US navy vessels blockaded Cuba, the Soviet leader, Nikita Khruschev, agreed to dismantle and remove the missiles and bombers in exchange for a secret American disarmament in Turkey.

    The blockade continued, with the constant risk of renewed conflict, until Nov 20, the day after Mr Macmillan's meeting with Gen Strong.

    Len Scott, professor of international politics at the University of Wales Aberystwyth and the author of Macmillan, Kennedy and the Cuban Missile Crisis, said yesterday: "The papers show how worried the British were about how the Americans reacted to the crisis and it is certainly the first time we knew this."
  2. Sounds like some dodgy int from the old codger.

    Nobody except "Bombs Away" Curtis Le May took this line.

    Besides, would Macmillan being in the loop have made any difference? IMHO, it would have just complicated things. As it is, things worked out pretty damn well and the decision-making process used by Excom is still used as a model in leadership and decision-making classes today. (See especially Thinking in Time: The uses of history for decision-makers by Richard Neustedt and Ernest May and Groupthink by Irving Janis.)

    Edit: Nice to see "Penfold" get a word in at the end. :D
  3. I thought JFK reined in his Generals after they proposed an airstrike and invading Cuba? Now we know that the Soviets had tactical nukes on the island and had given permission for the local commanders to use them if invaded
  4. I believe that there is some debate about this issue sparked off by access to Soviet archives and it is by no means clear that the full story has been unearthed. See the link below as a starter:

    Certainly the Soviets had in excess of a hundred nuclear warheads on Cuba during the crisis for the various tactical missile and artillery systems they had brought along. Had permission been granted to the local commander they would have been used in accordance with what was then standard doctrine, ie fire first and often. However, debate centers over whether or not the leadership would have issued the necessary permission, and it is suggested by some that recent archive finds indicate that they would not have risked a nuclear war on Castro's behalf.

    Frankly, I'm just glad we never found out.
  5. Just because the plan existed, it doesn't necessarily follow that it was the preferred option of the JCS. Le May was the only one strongly advocating it. Max Taylor IIRC, didn't want to know. Interestingly, Kennedy & McNamara had a sh1t-fit when they found out that part of the RoE for the naval "quarantine" included the firing of warning shots at the Captain's discretion- a SOP for blockades. They didn't like the idea of a stray round hitting a Soviet ship or one of their sub escorts.