Marine Recruiter in Fahrenheit Mourned

#1
http://www.comcast.net/entertainment/index.jsp?cat=ENTERTAINMENT&fn=/2006/07/08/430178.html

Marine Recruiter in 'Fahrenheit' Mourned
By SHARON COHEN, AP National Writer

LAKE ORION, Mich. - He was a stern-faced sniper _ and a soft-hearted Marine who handed out candy to kids in Iraq. He was a warrior who wrote poetry about life and death.

He was featured in Michael Moore's antiwar documentary, "Fahrenheit 9/11," portrayed as an overzealous Marine recruiter who targeted poor kids.

But Staff Sgt. Raymond Plouhar was far more complicated than that.

And it was that complicated man who died in Iraq in late June, as he served with some of the same men he had recruited years ago. It was that complex man who was buried Friday, by a family that honored his service but would never forget his humanity.

"He had a huge heart," says his widow, Leigha.

Plouhar was a Marine for 10 of his 30 years, but he had dreamed of joining the military ever since he was a little boy who liked to watch "M-A-S-H" on television and dress in fatigues and a camouflage shirt.

He entered the Corps straight out of high school, was trained as a sniper and traveled the world _ Bosnia, Sudan and Israel. He had a ramrod posture and a fierce pride in his appearance: He once ironed his uniform and polished its brass buttons for two hours before allowing his mom to photograph him.

"He told me lots of times that he learned what could be accomplished .. if you put your heart and soul in it _ and he put his heart and soul in the Marine Corps," says his father, also named Raymond. "He was gung-ho from the time he signed his name until the day he died."

His signature was a memorable one.

His birth certificate read Raymond James Byron Anthony Charles Plouhar _ he was named after all his grandfathers. He followed a long family tradition of military service that included a grandfather who earned a Purple Heart in World War II and an older sister, Toni, who was in the Army.

Plouhar carried a Bible from his grandfather, Raymond, to Iraq. He kept it in his left shirt pocket next to his heart. Tucked inside was a photo of his wife and their two sons, Raymond, 9, and Michael, 5.

As devoted as he was to the Marines, Plouhar had a full life outside the military. He liked to hunt and camp, take canoe trips and fish with his boys.

He was known as a charmer, a good talker, a champion of the underdog (always defending and befriending kids picked on in school) and though he was trained to fight and kill, he preferred the role of peacemaker.

"He didn't like turmoil," recalls his mother, Cynthia. "He wanted everybody to be happy, to get along. ... He'd say 'Life's too short to sweat the small stuff.'"

As family members gathered last week in their lakefront home 30 miles north of Detroit, they lined the walls and windows with photo collages that tell Raymond Plouhar's life in chapters.

There's the grinning kid with the protruding ears (a coach once joked he looked like a Volkswagen with the doors open) proudly holding up the bass he caught.

There's the sturdy athlete grappling with an opponent around a wrestling circle and posing in the green-and-white football uniform of the Lake Orion Dragons.

There's the young man in love, sitting with high school sweetheart, Leigha, on his dad's Harley on their way to the prom, then years later, together again, he in Marine blue, she in white, on their wedding day.

Then there's the tough-minded Marine in helmet and combat gear _ doling out candy from a plastic bag two months ago to schoolchildren in Iraq.

"He admired the Iraqi people," his father says. "He said, 'Dad, even though I can't understand a word they're saying, if we were back home ... we'd be buddies.'"

Plouhar was killed on June 26 by a roadside bomb in Anbar province in his second tour of duty in Iraq, weeks before he was to return home. He was assigned to the 3rd Battalion, 5th Marine Regiment, 1st Marine Division, I Marine Expeditionary Force in Camp Pendleton, Calif.

Plouhar's family says he had no qualms about returning to Iraq and he believed conditions had improved since his first tour in 2005.

"I never worried," Leigha says, "because ... in my head, he was indestructible and nothing could ever happen to him because he was so good at what he did."

His mother says her son preferred to be at the center of the action. In an undated entry in a blog on MySpace.com, Plouhar said "you can call me crazy" but he liked being in Iraq. "Someone has to do it plus I love what I do," he wrote.

Plouhar did step back from active duty for four years and worked as a recruiter in Flint so he could donate a kidney to his uncle.

It was as a recruiter that Plouhar was seen in Moore's award-winning "Fahrenheit 9/11." The segment shows Plouhar and another Marine in a mall parking lot in a depressed suburb of Flint; it suggests the two men were cynically hunting for poor teens to sign up, rather than go to a wealthy suburb where they'd likely be rejected.

Plouhar's father says his son told him he had been misled and believed he was being filmed for a documentary that would appear on the Discovery Channel. (Moore's office didn't return calls or e-mail messages seeking comment.)

"He cried when he found out what it really was," his father says. "He never dreamed that it was going to be something to slam the country, which he dearly loved."

The movie, to be precise, is primarily a criticism of the Bush administration's actions after the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks.

And yet, the elder Plouhar also says he doesn't see anything wrong with his son's actions. "If you really watched just the part with my son in it," he asks, "how could you not say that he was standing tall and proud?"

His parents say they've seen only the segment featuring their son. Leigha Plouhar says her husband asked her not to watch the film _ and she never has. Nor has Stephen Wandrie, his friend of 20 years, who says Plouhar was hurt by the film, but told him:

"'You know what? I know what I do is good for this country and every one of those people I'm recruiting _ those guys are my brothers.' "

In the past month, the bloodshed that has become part of the daily life in Iraq seemed to edge closer and closer. He was shaken up in two explosions.

Two weeks before he died, his mother says, he called and she could hear the strain in his voice. But he tried to be reassuring. "He said, I'll be all right. I don't have much longer. ... I'm ready to come home. I'm ready."

And yet he seemed prepared for the possibility he wouldn't.

In a poem he sent to his family last year _ a poem now enlarged to floor-to-ceiling size, and covering a wall of the Plouhar home _ Plouhar said he knew he could die serving his country and was ready to make the sacrifice.

"I will leave my loved ones, my kids, my wife ...," he wrote. "Do not feel pity for me, for this is my choice. ... This is me. This is who I am. I am a Marine to the very end."
RIP and Semper Fi
 
#4
RIP SSgt. Maybe we don't wear the same uniform but when the brown-hits-the-fan all-in-all it doesn't matter a damn.
 
#5
RIP fella,

I see once again that pathetic excuse for a human being M Moore manages to pish me off. I would dearly love to plant one right between his piggy , beady little eyes.

LT.
 
#6
Michael Moore's e-mail address: mmflint@aol.com
In case anyone wants it. I'm e-mailing this article to him.
 
#7
RIP to this US Marine, and all the fallen.
 
#8
Chief_Joseph said:
Michael Moore should be forced to appologize to his family. I dare him to look them in the eyes.

RIP and Semper Fi
Chief Joseph's original submission had the footnote 'written by a friend'. This has since been removed. Can you clear up the confusion over whether Sharon Cohen, Associated Press staff writer is in fact a friend?



The original story comes from an entertainment website, and as a mini-hagiography, it does succeed.
But my main point in responding is to ask why Chief Joseph didn't just let it lie and say R.I.P at the end? He felt the need to indulge himself by having a pop at Michael Moore, thereby making the first descent into the why's and wherefore's, which elicited my response.

I made a request for some balance. I can see that the man's friends and family and comrades will be mourning him - and I appreciate that. But staff writers at Entertainment News or whatever are there to hijack the relatives' grief and mould it into their perception of what the American Public demands - this is obvious in their choice of language.


You have to be very careful not to be used and manipulated by people with their own agenda.


There was an example back in 1982 of The Sun printing an exclusive story following an interview with the widow of posthumous V.C. winner Sergeant McKay. The story was a fiction dreamed up and published because the public demanded it. The interview never actually took place. This isn't quite as blatant, but it's along the same lines.
 
#9
frenchperson said:
Chief Joseph's original submission had the footnote 'written by a friend'. This has since been removed. Can you clear up the confusion over whether Sharon Cohen, Associated Press staff writer is in fact a friend?
No it didn't, I gave you an obituary for a dead Iraqi after you asked if anyone could show you a similar obituary for one of them. A good friend of mine wrote this http://gozarthetraveler.blogspot.com/2005/12/jimmy-was-kid-who-we-often-saw-while.html

I'll remove my comment if it so pleases you, but Moore's interviewer lied to him about the documentary and exploited him. I think he ought to answer for that.
 
#10
There are half a dozen posts on here between Frenchperson and I. Where have they gone?? Are the mods playing games or is it a snafu? If it has been pulled could the mod involved have the decency to PM me with the reason why??
 
#12
Check your PM's Guru.
 

Similar threads

New Posts

Latest Threads

Top