"Man" gives birth ... a rose by any other name?

#1
I thought the NAAFI was the best place (or, rather, the least worst place) to post this news that, to my view, shows the absurdity of some claims that a man or woman can "be" a woman or man by dint of some surgery and hormones.

Sex change man 'first male mother' - Yahoo!
A man is believed to have become Britain's first "male mother" by giving birth despite his sex change operation.
The man, thought to be in his 30s, had the child last year, said transgender support group the Beaumont Society.
It is possible for transgender men who were born women, who still have functioning ovaries and a uterus, to become pregnant while still identifying and living as men.
Joanna Darrell, from the Beaumont Society, said the man, who was born a woman but had had a sex change, had approached the society asking for advice about having a baby.
"We had a general inquiry to the Beaumont Society," she said. "The society, all it does is provide information and acts as an information hub for people to find data about specific things, and we are able to refer them to more specialist organisations.
"He came for some information and I referred him to GIRES."
GIRES, the Gender Identity Research and Education Society, is a charity that provides education, based on research into gender identity and intersex issues, to help improve the lives of those affected by the issues.
She said the man later got back in touch with the society to thank them for their help and say he had given birth to a baby.
"We sometimes get people coming back to say thanks for our help. He got back in touch and said he had had the baby."
She said as far as she knew the man's inquiry had been very unusual: "This is probably unique, in the two years that I have been a member of the society this is the only one that I have been able to refer on."
:roll: No, I'm not sorry, but if you manage to get pregnant and give birth, you are not a man, you're woman, no matter how much you "identify as" and "live as" a man ... the proof is in the pudding club membership.
 
#2
Jarrod, yer a dad!
 
#6
ps-anybody know wot regiment he/she/it came from? seems like an army/crab/matelot claim to fame!!
 
#8
ps-anybody know wot regiment he/she/it came from? seems like an army/crab/matelot claim to fame!!
Getting pregnant in the first place probably implies having sex with a man. But if you self identify as a man, and have sex with a man, then it probably means having the op to join Para Mortars ... apparently, they like to give as good as they get.
 
#9
Getting pregnant in the first place probably implies having sex with a man. But if you self identify as a man, and have sex with a man, then it probably means having the op to join Para Mortars ... apparently, they like to give as good as they get.
oh-that might get a responce- are you saying all paras are gay or just mortars-throw this open to all!!
 
#10
We have established - it's either a woman or a raging homo beefer.
 
#11
oh-that might get a responce- are you saying all paras are gay or just mortars-throw this open to all!!
Did you, er, follow the link in my post? I have to confess that I served (and not as a Para, I hasten to add - I passed the IQ test) in a different era (we had proper rifles with a decent calibre) and such things were a rarity or a bit of a joke rather than a way of life.

Of course, I suppose I should have added the usual caveat ...

Just because its' Yahoo
Doesn't mean it's Troo
 
#12
The world really has gone to the fucking dogs.
 
#13
The world really has gone to the fucking dogs.
Oh, I don't know. It sounds like a return to the lusty and deviant 18th Century after the stifling false morality of the Victorians and the dullard class obsessions of the 20s to the 50s. Men giving birth, everybody fucking whoever and whatever they like, women with cocks, Govt ministers with their reamed-out arseholes hanging to their knees. It's a pervert's banquet.
 
#14
Dante's descent into hell is well advanced, and Satan rules.

God help our descendents. (end of rant)
 
#15
So basically, the title should have read "Woman - who looks like a Bloke Has a Baby".

It's all sensational reporting bollocks and is as realistic as Legs in the "looking like a female" category.
 
#16
Sensationalist crap. 1000 yrs from now if a Tony Robbinson dug up his skeleton he would identify a Woman (wide hipe and lack of brow on skull).
 

BuggerAll

LE
Kit Reviewer
Book Reviewer
#17
I thought the NAAFI was the best place (or, rather, the least worst place) to post this news that, to my view, shows the absurdity of some claims that a man or woman can "be" a woman or man by dint of some surgery and hormones.

Sex change man 'first male mother' - Yahoo!


:roll: No, I'm not sorry, but if you manage to get pregnant and give birth, you are not a man, you're woman, no matter how much you "identify as" and "live as" a man ... the proof is in the pudding club membership.
I just wonder why you care. It really is no business of your how somebody else wants to chase health, wealth and happiness and live their life.

Or do you feel threatened by LGBT types?
 
#18
I just wonder why you care. It really is no business of your how somebody else wants to chase health, wealth and happiness and live their life.

Or do you feel threatened by LGBT types?
I personally don't feel threatened - I do however feel increasingly pissed off at the attention grabbing freaks
getting their grids plastered over the cover of every wimmin's glossy magazine going in the name of diversity, innit. If someone chooses to live and act like a walking freak show, crack on - but keep it to yourselves.
 
#19
I'm a pretty easy going bloke. If a woman has a sex change & wants to live as a man then there's no issue as far as I'm concerned. Having a baby in those circumstances is selfish in the extreme & shows that they probably rushed to get the Op in the first place.

Other than that: Woman Has Baby. Top journalism.
 
#20
"Where's the feotus going to gestate? Are you going to keep it in a box?"

Thought I'd mention it before the rest of yas. £5 to H4H for being first.
 

Similar threads

Latest Threads

Top