Long Tan Day

Discussion in 'Multinational HQ' started by Cutaway, Aug 18, 2006.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. Cutaway

    Cutaway LE Reviewer

    Today is the fortieth annversary of the Battle of Long Tan, a hard fought action by soldiers of 6 Royal Australian Regiment against phenomenal odds.

    I'm sadly shocked and surprised with monotonous regularity at the lack of knowledge of Long Tan, and even of the Aussie and Kiwi involvement in Viet Nam, by (mainly younger,) members of the British Army
    It exemplifies the dogged determination traditionally shown by ANZAC troops whose systems and training methods were based upon our own.


    Here's an account of the battle by the o/c D Coy 6 RAR, Maj Harry Smith MC (Retd.) - No apologies for the long post.

    "Much has been written about the Battle of Long Tan by others. Many authors have dwelt on the politics of why we were sent to Vietnam; and why we were sent out to locate a small force that had shelled the Base when it was obvious, perhaps in hindsight, that a large VC Force was in the area.
    Some, motivated by VC propaganda, have said we walked into a deliberate ambush. I have little time for the politics, theories or criticism which detract from the outstanding performance of my Company and all the Supporting Forces involved in the Battle.
    We were carrying out orders given by our Government to our Senior Commanders of the time.

    My orders early on the 18th August 1966 were to take D Company out to the Long Tan area, relieve B Company which had gone out the day before and located signs of vacated enemy mortar positions, and try and locate the VC force that had shelled the Base.
    My Commander indicated a Weapons Platoon and protection, perhaps 50-60 VC, probably long gone.
    Despite statements made in hindsight by various intelligence people, no indication was given to me of any larger force in the area, other than perhaps odd D445 Local Force Companies.

    We quickly prepared for the operation and left Base about 1100, moving across the grassy fields to the East, to the music from the Col Joye and Little Pattie Concert.
    About 1300 we arrived at B Coy area. I went around with Major Noel Ford, a close friend from 1952 OCS days, and we looked at the various VC mortar positions and tracks.
    B Company had swept the area to the East (to a hut), and North East, and found no sign of VC in the area. They had spent a quiet night, had sent half the Company back to Base earlier, with the rest departing about 1500. There was no indication of any enemy actively in the area since the shelling on the 16th.

    I discussed the situation by radio with my Battalion Commander, suggesting that despite tracks to the NE and S, that my gut feeling was to patrol East to our Artillery gun range limit. I recall saying, lightly, "On the toss of a coin, go East young man"! After giving orders, we headed East, then with new tracks in the rubber, I gave orders for a widely-dispersed two (platoons)-up advance through the rubber plantation generally ESE parallel to a formed dirt track, with 11 Platoon on the right, along the track; 10 Platoon to the left; Company Headquarters centre rear, and 12 Platoon rear (reserve).

    [​IMG]

    Soon after, at about 1540, a small VC patrol walked in from the South, nonchalantly, chatting, not looking, right into the middle of 11 Platoon.
    11 Platoon opened fire, killing one, capturing an AK47, and then went on to assault the hut area where it was thought the VC had withdrawn to, but the area was clear. They regrouped into three sections up and continued advancing.

    A few VC 60mm mortar bombs were fired from the South, landing just East of the Company. I ordered a small move across to the West, and the Artillery FO organized Counter-Bombardment. To the best of my knowledge, no more VC 60mm or 82mm mortars, or their 75mm guns, were fired into the Company area, despite the large number that could have been used by the VC if they had been prepared for the ensuing battle.

    This diversion placed the main Company group a little further away from 11 Platoon, but into a slight reverse-slope area that was to later prove invaluable, providing some protection from direct VC fire.

    11 Platoon continued to advance SE, and soon ran into heavy VC MG fire, which caused casualties. 11 Platoon went into a defensive layout, and after about 20 minutes under fire were then assaulted by a large enemy force.
    It become obvious from radio conversations and the firing that 11 Platoon was pinned down and taking heavy casualties.
    Our Artillery FO called in gunfire to support 11 Platoon, and I gave orders to 10 Platoon to swing around and assault from the left (North), with the aim of taking pressure off 11 Platoon so they could withdraw back into a Company defensive position.
    It started to rain heavily - the usual afternoon monsoon downpour.
    Then radio communications with 11 Platoon ceased.
    My worst thoughts were that they may have been over-run.

    10 Platoon then came under heavy fire and were halted. I ordered them to withdraw with their casualties while they were able, back into the Company area, and then sent 12 Platoon, less one Section to protect the casualties in the Aid Post area, to the right to try and assist 11 Platoon.
    Coy HQ moved off behind 12 Platoon but it soon became obvious that neither I nor the FO could control the battle on the move and we remained in what was to become the defensive area for the rest of the battle, with some protection from small arms fire by slightly higher ground between us and the VC.
    We had neither the time, the opportunity nor the tools to dig protection trenches in the mud between the young rubber trees.

    At about this time we started running short of ammunition, and I requested helicopter re-supply. This arrived some time after, no mean feat by the pilots in monsoon rain conditions, and was dropped through the trees right into our position during a lull in the VC onslaught, and the ammunition was quickly distributed.
    Without this re-supply, there is little doubt we would not have survived.

    The survivors from 11 Platoon eventually managed to withdraw, back to 12 Platoon, then back to the Company area, where we re-organized the platoons into a defensive layout as the VC forces started to assault in waves, to be cut down by our massive artillery fire and our own machine-gun and rifle fire.

    It was also about this time that I requested B Company to return to assist, and I was informed that A Company was being sent out from the Base in APC's.
    I had requested air strikes, but the USAF fighters could not see the area for rain and dropped their ordnance to the East, later found to have taken heavy toll in VC rear areas, as did the US Army heavy guns.

    The VC assaults continued, but each was repulsed by our Artillery and small arms fire.
    The VC would then withdraw, re-organise and assault again, with tremendous MG and small arms tracer fire lighting up the fading daylight like a million fireflies.
    Our FO moved the gunfire around onto the VC, and by this time we had the support of all 24 or so Australian, NZ 105mm and US Army 155mm guns. They fired over 3000 rounds in support of D Company that afternoon.
    During lulls, between VC assaults we were able to walk around, tend to casualties and re-distribute weapons and ammunition ready for the next onslaught.

    At last light, B Company HQ and the one platoon arrived, just as we fired on enemy force moving around to the West trying to get to our rear. Then the APCs and A Company arrived, dispersing the VC flanking move.
    All the VC then withdrew, and as we later discovered, fled hurriedly East leaving behind many bodies, wounded, weapons, equipment and fortunately our own dead, wounded and weapons, untouched, in the original 11 Platoon area

    During the night we withdrew West to the edge of the rubber and evacuated all the casualties sustained in the final company area.
    The following morning, as part of a major Task Force advance named Operation "Smithfield', we moved back into the area, recovering the 11 Platoon dead and wounded, and burying all the enemy dead.
    We took 3 VC prisoner. I am aware that perhaps another 2 or 3 were shot, one as an act of mercy because of horrific head-wounds, and a couple because they made a move to shoot, but not the 17 "murdered" as claimed by one misguided media report in a 1986 article.

    Some say we exaggerated the enemy dead. I can say that we all saw a large number of bodies and that the 245 enemy dead were counted and buried in specific areas by different units with no reason to fabricate the numbers.
    VC records later captured by US Forces indicated the total VC losses at Long Tan were in the order of 500 dead and 750 wounded.

    Our casualties were 17 KIA, 21 WIA, with another 1 KIA and WIA from the APCs.
    VC media propaganda and over Radio Hanoi and in newspapers was to the effect they had won a glorious victory over the Australians forces, destroying one complete battalion of 600, several tanks and two aircraft !

    Looking Back:
    30 years down the track, I am aware of other versions of the Battle, especially by cynics siding with the VC version, claiming we were ambushed.
    I can say without any doubt there was NO ambush.
    The Regimental NVA force was resting in a typical defensive area in jungle well to the East and only moved out to attack 11 Platoon after the VC contact near the hut.
    There was no prepared ambush killing ground into where all the VC fire, Claymore mines, RPG's, Artillery, and mortars could have been directed.
    In fact there were no 82mm mortars or 75mm guns used during the Battle. The VC attacks took place inside our gun range.
    And there was no cut-off force to attack any relief force at the only river crossing that could be used.
    All that adds up to - NO ambush, just a pure chance encounter.
    The VC were obviously aroused by the 11 Platoon contact with a "clearing patrol" which had no idea we were in the area.
    This was confirmed by one of the few factual VC statements - from the former Commander of D445 in a videotaped interview.

    There is absolutely no doubt in my mind that Long Tan was an encounter battle where 108 soldiers of D Coy survived continual frontal assaults mounted by battalions of a reinforced NVA Regiment in the order of some 2500 NVA and VC troops.
    The battle developed from a Platoon contact with a VC Patrol, to an assault on that platoon by probably two VC Companies, then to Battalion attacks on our final Company defensive position.
    We survived by a combination of our own training, discipline and firepower; the massive Australian, NZ and US Army artillery support; the RAAF helicopter ammunition resupply; USAF bombing in the VC rear echelons; and the eventual relief by B Coy, A Coy, and the APC's.
    While the VC Forces had the theoretical capacity and superiority of about 8 to l to reorganise and take on about two companies and some APCs, they chose to withdraw.
    I believe they had had enough, were not really aware of the small strength of the Australian force, and had sustained too many casualties to continue.

    Why the Task Force Base was shelled has never been answered. It drew two companies of 6RAR "out of the mountain", but they were not molested while they sat around the edge of the rubber plantation on the 17th and 18th And where were all their mortars and guns on the 18th?

    North Vietnamese versions of the Battle have to be treated as suspect. They do not stand up to logical examination.
    The VC are obviously not going to change their original story of a historic and successful ambush of a battle at Long Tan, in hindsight, there is ample evidence now available to show that the whole of VC 5 Division was in the area.
    To the East and North-West, and that the Mortars and Artillery not used at Long Tan were probably to the West, perhaps to be used to support an attack on the TF Base and the other Regiment to the North, as a cut-off for any US road relief force.
    The prisoners said at the time they were going to attack the TF Base.
    Former NVA Officers have followed the Party-Line of a successful ambush of the Australian Forces.
    With, the resources of the Internet, perhaps one day we might hear answers to all the questions from someone who was there, and who knows just what 5 Division intended, where the VC mortars and guns were and what was the factual series of events from the VC side ?

    I am proud to have commanded Delta Company 6RAR. D Coy was awarded the United States Presidential Citation for the Battle.
    I deeply regret the loss of life on both sides, and the grief caused to the families.
    Both sides at the time were simply soldiers carrying out their duties as required by their respective Governments, now engaged in peaceful activities."


    I for one will be raising a few wets to the Aussies tonight, and especially the eighteen young men who died forty years ago.


    At the going down of the sun,
    And in the morning,
    We will remember them.
     
  2. Cuts

    Read the book a while back, all very impressive. I was thinking of it when I watched Mel Gibson bigging it up as a Septic.

    Shouldn't he be backing a film to record his own countrymen's efforts ?

    I too will raise a glass or eight, luckily it's also my birthday so all is prepared.


    Whiffler
     
  3. Cutaway

    Cutaway LE Reviewer

    Which book ?
    A number of good ones have been published, Burstall, McAulay, Grandin and Lt Col Mollison have all written accounts, and there are probably a host more out there.

    Glibcnut will either hate the nation that gave him an education as they're predominantly of Brit extraction, else he'll re-write it as thousands of redcoats stampeding through the ulu pausing only to bayonet babies, burn cathedrals and slap women, before being beaten into a cowering mob by a long-haired seventh Dan Nokandoripyourlipsoff expert who flinches while shooting blanks.
    But enough of the snivelling anti-semitic drunk, he's not worth the bandwidth.

    Have a good evening & remember those who went before us.
     
  4. Which book ?. Err ... dunno. It was a while back, title might have been '.....something ... the battle for Long Tan'.

    If my memory was any good before, the 3 pints of Pimm's I've just had will not have helped. All that comes to mind now is "This here's a wattle, the emblem of our land. You can stick it in a bottle, you can hold it in your hand. Amen"

    Bonzer guys!.
     
  5. Suppose I shall pop over to the sports n social and down a few in memoriam!
     
  6. whiffler - snap ! My b'day too !
     
  7. I have a copy of McAulay's book:

    McAulay, L. (1986): The Battle of Long Tan: The Legend of ANZAC Upheld, London, Arrow Books.

    It was given to me several years ago and I have to say I think it is one of the best acounts of a small unit action ever written.
     
  8. Cutaway

    Cutaway LE Reviewer

    Aye Inf/MP, but it was a small unit action for the Aussies only !
     
  9. For the record, Mel Gibson is a Septic. He was born in New York and his dad moved the family to Australia when Mel was 12 so he and his brothers could avoid the Vietnam draft.
     
  10. A raised glass to the aussies & kiwis (other than when the cricket is on :D ). Living in S'pore there is always good banter with these boys but that takes nothing away from the bravery of such folk in these circumstances - long may they be friends of the UK

    Re Gibson - I thought he was a Yank who'd moved to Oz. Regardless he's a shallow minded c*nt & the last thing the Aussies really need as a means of praising good honest squaddies.

    lancslad
     
  11. I read one of the books a while ago too, and remember being impressed by accounts of the Padre too.

    I remember thinking how much is to be said for well aimed single shots.

    I shall certainly raise a glass to them, and like the officer mentioned above regret all the deaths, say a prayer for all those who died there, as they were all regular soldiers doing their duty.

    But the gooks don't get a drink, just a prayer :)