Like/Dis-like or voting buttons

Guns

ADC
Moderator
Book Reviewer
#1
There is the Like button, which is nice. But many posts on here I dis-agree with or don't like and short of posting it is hard to gauge how bone a post is to the collective ARRSE.

It may help reduce the flaming we see where personal insults become the norm if we had a dis-like button or even like they do in some Comments areas on newspapers a plus/minus voting systems.

Just a thought and await response.
 
#6
Wouldn't a "you're a ****" button be more widely used?
What this site really needs is a button which can express any sentiment the user would want.

What would happen is that there'd be a box at the bottom of the page you could type into, and then a button next to it (for the sake of argument, let's say that this button would be called "Post Quick Reply"). Hit the button and whatever you'd typed would go on the page.
 

B_AND_T

MIA
Book Reviewer
#7
How about a "You post like Afghan Kandak" button?
 
P

PrinceAlbert

Guest
#8
True. It would with most of your posts.
You do realise that you actually de-value the "like" button don't you. Hence I try to post stuff you won't like. If I post enough you'll get "like button withdrawal syndrome" and hopefully die. Slowly.
 
#9
How about a "I like boiled eggs" or "I like sheds" button? or a "your all cnuts" button? Amazingly-Enough-I-Dont-Give-A-Shit.jpg
 
#10
There is the Like button, which is nice. But many posts on here I dis-agree with or don't like and short of posting it is hard to gauge how bone a post is to the collective ARRSE.

It may help reduce the flaming we see where personal insults become the norm if we had a dis-like button or even like they do in some Comments areas on newspapers a plus/minus voting systems.

Just a thought and await response.
I’m sympathetic with your point, but, although I suspect I’m in the minority, I ultimately can’t agree. One of the reasons ARRSE is so successful is that it not only allows diverse, even hostile, opinions to be expressed, but actively encourages robust and open exchanges of viewpoints. A “dislike” button could discourage some posters, thereby not only reducing the traffic that the site needs, but also making some posters reluctant to express views and weakening the potential for interesting debate, even if interesting for all the “wrong” reasons. I’d rather ARRSE was a little chaotic at times than an echo chamber, or just the stomping ground of cliques and internet warriors. There are already too many posters here waiting to see which way a thread will go before daring to offer an opinion for fear of upsetting the big boys.

Naturally, this being ARRSE there will those who would actively engage in even more baiting and trolling just to drive up their “dislike” count, so exacerbating the problem. Sanctions are already available and have recently been increased in scope. It might be an idea to see if they improve things first?

Oh, and I don't care if people don't like this post. They can't vote it down (yet!) :eye:
 

FORMER_FYRDMAN

LE
Book Reviewer
#11
Here's a radical idea. If you don't like something, post a response explaining why and then the other poster can respond to you and you can respond to them and then, maybe, other people will join in and then there will be a debate and then the forums will be just like real internet discussion boards.
 
#12
You do realise that you actually de-value the "like" button don't you. Hence I try to post stuff you won't like. If I post enough you'll get "like button withdrawal syndrome" and hopefully die. Slowly.
What are you dribbling about? Can you try to say that in plain English, please?
 
#14
You do realise that you actually de-value the "like" button don't you. Hence I try to post stuff you won't like. If I post enough you'll get "like button withdrawal syndrome" and hopefully die. Slowly.
What are you dribbling about? Can you try to say that in plain English, please?
I think he thinks that you are a cock.
 
#17
A “dislike” button could discourage some posters, thereby not only reducing the traffic that the site needs, but also making some posters reluctant to express views and weakening the potential for interesting debate, even if interesting for all the “wrong” reasons.
Now read the rest of the thread that followed you posting this. "Interesting debate"? The only thing making people reluctant to express their views is the dribblers on this site who can't form a cogent argument so resort to lobbing insults. Thank god for ROPs.

I agree it's not a great idea, if only because the same dribblers would follow people around "disliking" every single they write. The Real Dave Evans springs to mind, but to be honest, his target deserves it.

A vote up/down might be nice in the serious forums, it would be very helpful in the ACF forum to flag the idiots that feel the need to respond to every thread just to bait the AI's. I've seen several threads in the Int cell go down the pan because of two bell-ends arguing and then the thread gets locked. Mod them down out of the way. Slashdot.org's moderation system works reasonably well in that regard.
 
#19
You do realise that you actually de-value the "like" button don't you. Hence I try to post stuff you won't like. If I post enough you'll get "like button withdrawal syndrome" and hopefully die. Slowly.

How is it possible for one person to de-value the "like" button? Do you mean to say that ALL your posts are aimed at me?
 

Similar threads

Latest Threads

Top