• This is a stand-to for an incoming competition, one of our most expensive yet.
    Later this week we're going to be offering the opportunity to Win £270 Rab Neutrino Pro military down jacket
    Visit the thread at that link above and Watch it to be notified as soon as the competition goes live

Lebanon - a reassessment :A Poll

Was Hezbollah Strengthen or Weaken by war ?

  • Strengthen

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Weaken

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Undecided

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
#1
http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1157913624183&pagename=JPost/JPArticle/Printer

AN EGYPTIAN commentator, Ali al-Ibrahim, noted recently that the Arabs had learned to differentiate between victories on television and real victories in the field. How long will it take the Israelis to do likewise?

Israel's achievements in the war should not be underestimated, all the more so because they were attained despite the unbelievably incompetent and indecisive handling of the military campaign by the triumvirate of Olmert, Peretz and Halutz. They have failed us miserably and must go. .................

Whether the achievements of the war prove lasting or not is another question. Can the Lebanese led by Fuad Seniora's government build on the new political realities that the war has created? Will they be able to withstand the pressure that is bound to come from the Iran-Syria-Hizbullah axis that will seek to undo the consequences of the war and reestablish the status quo ante? Only time will tell, but these are questions that would not even have been asked had it not been for the war against Hizbullah.
 
#2
Garbage

Israel's achievements in the war should not be underestimated, all the more so because they were attained despite the unbelievably incompetent and indecisive handling of the military campaign by the triumvirate of Olmert, Peretz and Halutz. They have failed us miserably and must go.
Anyone else see the contradiction here?
 
#3
PartTimePongo said:
Garbage

Israel's achievements in the war should not be underestimated, all the more so because they were attained despite the unbelievably incompetent and indecisive handling of the military campaign by the triumvirate of Olmert, Peretz and Halutz. They have failed us miserably and must go.
Anyone else see the contradiction here?
Funnily enough, yes! Obviously missed by the 'faithful'. :)

On second thoughts, maybe no contradiction. Considering that the 'war' was pretty much a fiasco - if not a complete failure - from the Israeli point of view, it's hard to understand how you could underestimate the achievements. How much lower can you go than rock-bottom?
 
#4
I didn't vote in this poll, because of the vagueness of the proposition.
I have instead split it into three different catagories

Hezbollah weakened militarily - undoubtedly. They lost position and equipment.

Weakened Strategically - I think so, especially if the UN shows the teeth they are supposed to at any future Hezbollah (or indeed Israeli) violence. If they have their arms taken away from them by a Lebanese led effort then it will have undoubtedly weakened them - I know this is doubtful but we can always hope.

Weakened Politically - Rather the opposite unfortunately. In the short and medium term I think that they have had their hand strengthened. It will be up to the opposition in the Lebanon to fight the good fight in this arena
 
#5
Well put Sven, hence my own " undecided " vote.

Militarily, HB have taken a kicking (even though the Israelis performed poorly considering their massive superiority). But they were always going to, and they don't give a toss how many new martyrs they have to show cr*p videos of on Al jazeera, in fact the more the merrier! Politically, they are far stronger; they now have the inaccurate reputation of being able to beat the Israelis in a stand up fight.

Ah well, the sooner we find an alternative to oil the better, then the whole of the middle east can be left to its own devices, or turned into a glasspaved parking lot, whichever seems like the best idea...
 

Similar threads

Latest Threads

Top