Leaving the EU now - attractive, but is the timing wrong?

Discussion in 'Current Affairs, News and Analysis' started by FORMER_FYRDMAN, Nov 22, 2012.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:


    FORMER_FYRDMAN LE Book Reviewer

    I read this article expecting to throw toast round the room and kick the dog (if it hadn't died last year). Whilst I loathe the EU and all it stands for, I found myself agreeing with much of this, particularly that, if we jump now, we don't know what we're jumping to and we make it very easy for the Eurocrats to pin the current sorry mess entirely on the UK in the minds of their already very dim citizens and cause trouble - Hollande desperately needs a scapegoat as his (and Ed Milliband's) preferred economic strategy is collapsing around his ears.

    Overall, I'm convinced that, if you believe as I do that the EU and the Euro is structurally flawed, we should follow a policy of not devolving more power to Brussels, extracting as much as we can from Paris and Berlin to stop us rocking the boat and then play a long game by shaping our exit strategy as response to the inevitable EU collapse and with the long term strategy of taking as many Northern European countries with us as possible when we go.

    Should we be opportunistic or will a more long-term strategy be a better approach?

    EU budget: it is selfish of Eurosceptics to try to force David Cameron’s hand - Telegraph
  2. Do we leave the ship whist at a convenient port or wait until everyone is jumping into the life-rafts?
  3. Leave now
    There is no price that could be to high.
    • Like Like x 8

    FORMER_FYRDMAN LE Book Reviewer

    I like the idea of denying the Scots Nats any opportunity to play games with Brussels and of the chance to abscond with a reformed Northern EU which could actually be of value without the French, much of the Warsaw Pact and multiple assorted Mafiosi.
    • Like Like x 3
  5. My view also, I commend the idea to the house!
    • Like Like x 2
  6. It reminds me of 'whatever happened to baby jane' the bit where Jane says 'Blanche, you aint' ever gonna leave this place and you ain't ever gonna sell it.
    • Like Like x 2
  7. Just join the EEA - comprising Norway, Iceland, and Lichtenstein..they get all the benfits of free movement of goods and people without the rubbish from Brussels.
    • Like Like x 1
  8. If only.

    We would still be influenced by EU policies without having a say in them. And the EU would become a lot less economically liberal without the UK pushing for it. It is out of the question for a country of the UK's size within Europe to be left out at the table where important decisions on European policies are made.

    Unless you can tow the UK into the middle of the Atlantic the effects of the EU won't go away. Deal with it.

    Instead of tabloid fused hissy fits from the sidelines, the UK should change the EU from within and become a major player, rather than leave the french and germans to it.

    So a lot of this "shit from Brussels" won't change if we're in out of the EU, we just won't be able to influence it.

    This is what Ulf Sverdrup, head of Norwegian Institute of International Affairs has to say on Norways position:

    BBC News - Viewpoints: How experts see UK role in EU

    All in all the EU is just a handy scapegoat for the tabloids.
    • Like Like x 2
  9. Sod it, lets just get the feck off the boat and see how it goes. Can't be worse than what we already have. Besides, the way the EU Politicos ignore our PM, no-one will notice we've****ed off til its too late anyway
    • Like Like x 2
  10. So basically this is the scottish independence thread.
    • Like Like x 1
  11. Those buggers can feck off too :p
  12. And neither do most of the anti-EU population of this country, who, along with those who dislike Muslims, aren't exactly sure why, but as it appeared on their Facebook page the other day, they ticked 'like' and 'shared' it.

    That wasn't a dig at you by the way.
    • Like Like x 2
  13. Well rather than delaying we save £53 million for each day we are out. So the sooner the better for me !
    • Like Like x 3

    FORMER_FYRDMAN LE Book Reviewer

    BBC experts? Log-rolling vested interest representatives from long-standing EU cheerleaders more like.
    • Like Like x 2
  15. theres always a 'worse', and people who live in rich, democratic countries with rights of work, abode and free trade across a political/trading block that stretches from Shannon to the Belorussian border and contains 500m people have an awful lot more to lose than anyone for whom there truly is 'it can't get worse'.

    for anyone in the UK to use the phrase indicates they have an IQ of around room temperature.

    the EFTA members pay a membership fee to the EU, but unlike us, they just get to obey the rules, rather than shape them - one would have to be almost sectionable to believe that was a good idea.

    personally i think that a re-adjustment is in all interests, and is likely: it seems increasingly difficult to maintain an EU that has both Eurozone and non-Eurozone members within the current structures, and those who are pro-integration would like to be able to get on with it without the opposition that the UK and others have.

    a free trade agreement between the Euroozone - however that pans out - and the UK is in both parties interests: even outside the EZ, the UK is 1/7th of all economic activity in the EU. Germany is not for one moment going to consider losing such a valuable export market just because we no longer wish to be part of the Common Agricultural Policy, so a deal will be done, regardless of the squeeling of Barroso and his ilk.

    on of the good things about the Euro crisis has been the demonstration that it is not the EU structures which make the big decisions when the shit hits the fan, its the member governments in their naked self interest with the EU gimp making the tea and buttering the bagels while the Big Boys (Girls called Angela) running the show.
    • Like Like x 1