• ARRSE have partnered with Armadillo Merino to bring you an ARRSE exclusive, generous discount offer on their full price range.
    To keep you warm with the best of Merino gear, visit www.armadillomerino.co.uk and use the code: NEWARRSE40 at the checkout to get 40% off!
    This superb deal has been generously offered to us by Armadillo Merino and is valid until midnight on the the 28th of February.

Lawyers for Somali Pirates Blame US Navy and FBI for Hostage Deaths

#2
Not at all. If you were the 'defense attorney' for these fellows you too would argue in their favour; that's the job of legal defence counsel. Whether that defence will wash is another story; I'd like to see the four go for an early bath, personally.
 
#3
Not at all. If you were the 'defense attorney' for these fellows you too would argue in their favour; that's the job of legal defence counsel. Whether that defence will wash is another story; I'd like to see the four go for an early bath, personally.
Believe me, I fully understand how our "system" works.....or not. Setting aside the lawyering aspect, I think it is a fitting metaphor for the "blame others" meme that seems to characterize much of the world in which we live.
 
#4
Not at all. If you were the 'defense attorney' for these fellows you too would argue in their favour; that's the job of legal defence counsel. Whether that defence will wash is another story; I'd like to see the four go for an early bath, personally.
Believe me, I fully understand how our "system" works.....or not. Setting aside the lawyering aspect, I think it is a fitting metaphor for the "blame others" meme that seems to characterize much of the world in which we live.

It's your fault I'm getting fat.
 

Wordsmith

LE
Book Reviewer
#15
With such tortured "logic" as this I am even more convinced we are increasingly living in an "Alice in Wonderland" world where up is down and in is out.

Defense: Navy Actions Led to Pirate Hostage Deaths | Military.com
I believe lawyers have to act on their clients instructions, so this lawyer could in theory be doing what his clients ask.

I'm perfectly sure that his 20% of the multi-million dollar damages that could be claimed if he gets his clients off using this defence played absolutely no role in formulating this strategy.

Wordsmith
 
#17
Followed by.. "she started to scream so I had to kill her to stop getting caught"

A defence only likely to stand up if it was a UK court and you were able to prove you came from a racially oppressed minority who had a bad start in life. Moral of story - get stopped by Royal Navy
 
#18
With such tortured "logic" as this I am even more convinced we are increasingly living in an "Alice in Wonderland" world where up is down and in is out.

Defense: Navy Actions Led to Pirate Hostage Deaths | Military.com
If the seals had been a little more vigorous in their attack by shooting dead ALL of the pirates, who were obviously "fighting to the death" ;-) the problem with the trial would not have occured!!
Methinks this should always be the course of action with these scum, rather than give them some medecines, water & halal food to see them safely home ala Royal Navy :-(
 
#20
Seems reasonable to me:

Killing hostages generally leads to a considerable devaluation of their ransom, ergo reasonable to assume they aren't in immediate danger. Yank warship intervenes, keen to show a hard line as a deterrent to other pirates. Pirates try to warn off the Yanks with an RPG, fail, and assume the game is up so off their hostages to show an equally hard line to deter future rescuers. You can argue a tit for tat victory over the pirates, but it might have been nice to ask the hostages if they minded being collateral damage.
 

Latest Threads