So, some are very good, albeit, if you just fall under 1 heirachy otherwise you have to produce them for every single establishment under your command (what a nightmare for places like MOD, PJHQ etc). We have been given recomended reports to produce, I could go through the faults with them on here but it would fill a page. What are your opinions on the dictated reports that we are told we have to produce, and what has been your ICT's comments on them. We have run off BPG's for all of them and they do not really tell you what we, as HR, should be looking for, in a pass or fail inspection how does this help, it seems to me that they (as well as alot of the inspection criteria, (do not make it pass or fail if you, DSPS(A), are waiting on feedback before making a structured inspection criteria) are down to unit interpretation as to what we do with them. We (HR) need clearer guidance from DSPS(A), as they are the department that have produced this criteria on what we (HR) and Bde SPS Inspection teams should be looking at. Oh, and I have it from a good source that DSPS(A) look at this site daily, please, please, make the inspection critiria uniformed (more detail), at the moment it's hugely open to interpretation and inspection teams in all Bde's are having to play it as they see it, all looking at different things and taking a different approach as per their perception. It should not be a Pass or Fail at this point in time, yes, once feedback has been recieved by Bde's and passed to DSPS(A) then put out a more detailed criteria and a pass or fail inspection, at least all will know where they stand, and if the other services follow suite it will have been properly tried and tested by us first. feedback please.