Is this reasonable

Discussion in 'The Intelligence Cell' started by Closet_Jibber, Dec 13, 2011.

?
  1. No - He has no right to use force

    16 vote(s)
    9.0%
  2. No - He used too much force

    2 vote(s)
    1.1%
  3. Yes - He can use force in these circumstances

    119 vote(s)
    67.2%
  4. Yes - He could have used more force to achieve his aim

    40 vote(s)
    22.6%

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. Yes - But this is a learning exercise for me. Just seeing what "Joe Public" would make of this should they find themselves on Jury Duty dealing with an assault case.
     
  2. From a legal standpoint I have no idea but from the question of whether socially he did the right thing then yes!

    Maybe if more people were prepared to intervene the twats who think the rest of us owe them a living might think twice. I wish I had half his guts, but I'd be too worried about having a bloody knife pulled on me.
     
    • Like Like x 8
  3. Big man did not want to late for his 10 pie dinner so I say he was within his rights to throw the oike off.
     
  4. I read that as "ScroteRail"!

    I think the "Big Man" was absolutely justified and, given the circumstances, quite restrained. He didn't give the little git the kicking he deserved.

    (I may have removed my "I would have kicked his head in" hat, but my "I would have kicked his head in" boots are still firmly on my feet...)
     
    • Like Like x 1
  5. Yep. The guy without a ticket was holding the entire train up (causing delays/missed changes for every passenger on that train and on every other train on the line) and BTP would have taken half an hour to get there. The guy's actions were, in my opinion, proportionate to the problem. It would have been a different matter if he'd kicked him in.
     
    • Like Like x 3
  6. Not sure about scots law but, technically, he's committed an assault. He's neither defending himself, others, or property. Neither is he, I believe, acting using any person powers to effect an arrest as he simply throws him off.

    Though he's done the right thing there by helping throw the fare dodger off the train he has no legal power (that I know of) to do so.

    I imagine the Daily Wail readership will want him knighted in the new years honour list, I can't imagine them being so supportive if it was a copper roughly throwing him off.
     
    • Like Like x 3
  7. He was firm with the lad but never punched or kicked out. No different to how a bouncer or policeman would act in similar circumstances. The problem is the legitimacy of his intervention. Are his actions empowered and legally justified after agreeing with the conducter to get involved. I will be interested to see how this turns out. Hopefully common sense will prevail and it will be forgotten, hopefully the police wont go looking for a scalp.
     
  8. Shhh - Stop spoiling the fun.
     
  9. My bad.
     
  10. Though he's done the right thing there by helping throw the fare dodger off the train he has no legal power (that I know of) to do so.

    Yep, legally it appears he was wrong to do so, although I doubt a jury would find him guilty.
    I'd buy him a beer at least

    Of course not it would be police brutality, wail, gnash of teeth etc etc
     
  11. Speaking as a UK officer (Not a lawyer) so I can only go by English not Scots law.

    Basically down here there are several ways this is legal.. and even if it was a bit shady I wouldn't arrest the 'big guy'.

    First of all under common law any person has the power to use reasonable force to prevent a breach of the peace and the young twat swearing and shouting at an old man which could quite easily turn physical is a breach of the peace.

    Also under section 3 of the criminal law act any person has the power to use reasonable force to prevent crime. The lad is comitting several crimes including fraud, public order and so on.

    Theres no case (In England) for the big man to answer and if I'd attended he would have gotten a handshake and hopefully a letter from an inspector/sgt thanking him for his civic duty.

    DISCLAIMER - Mileage may vary with other officers.
     
    • Like Like x 11
  12. Out of curiosity if my mate catches a oike stealing from his shop can he legally detain him whilst awaiting for the rozzers to turn up?
     
  13. Yep, problem arises when force goes beyond mere detention/prevention and into vigilantee/revenge.

    Obvioulsy he catches the scrote and the scrote will fight - You're still allowed to defend yourself with reasonable force, you just have to make sure your proportionate and the force is legal, necessary and accountable.

    IE holding him in an arm lock because he was getting fighty and you explain that - not a problem.

    If they give up and you start stamping on their hands and rubbing their face into the floor - Illegal.

    Its the same with all the burglar stabbings people have been found with no case to answer for lately - They used reasonable force to defend themselves.