• ARRSE have partnered with Armadillo Merino to bring you an ARRSE exclusive, generous discount offer on their full price range.
    To keep you warm with the best of Merino gear, visit www.armadillomerino.co.uk and use the code: NEWARRSE40 at the checkout to get 40% off!
    This superb deal has been generously offered to us by Armadillo Merino and is valid until midnight on the the 28th of February.

Iraqis "tortured by Soldiers"

#1
This old chestnut has just arisen . The MoD has not contested a decision that Iraqis were "tortured by he Army". Apparently compensation to all concerned could total a million pounds because the treatment contravened Article two of the European Convention of Human Rights.

Nice to see that Iraq is now part of Europe. Roll on world domination.

(Tried to get a link from T' Daily Telegraph site but couldn't do it.)
 
#3
The situation was managed in the wrong way. The relatives of the killed man had to be proposed by significant compensation - 100,000 Pounds or even more. There was no need for lengthy process, investigations and expensive trial. So the case would be forgotten now.

But as it was handled the case heavily contributed to anti-British propaganda, exposed HM armed forces in the negative light.
 
#6
lanky said:
Basa was beaten to death in British custody and it is only right that an apology is made and compensation made.
My point is this: Why was the European Human Rights Act used when the "offences" took place in Iraq which geographically is outside of Europe?
 
#7
Because there is not such thing as a Eurpean Human Rights Act. What you are referring to is the Human Rights Act 1998 which is part of British Law. And British Troops operate under British Laws.

Edit: Yours is a good point though.
 
#8
Scabster_Mooch said:
Because there is not such thing as a Eurpean Human Rights Act. What you are referring to is the Human Rights Act 1998 which is part of British Law. And British Troops operate under British Laws.

Edit: Yours is a good point though.
But the Telegraph, which is a bit reliable for news than some others, said Des Browne, the Parttime Defence Secretary, admitted that the MOD had breached article two of the European Convention on Human Rights, the right to life, in relation to Mr Mousa.
 
#9
The European Convention on Human Rights was not set up to define illegal acts carried out by the worlds people on Europeans, or European malfaence on Europeans but acts carried out by Europeans on the worlds people (which includes other Europeans)
 
#11
What was done to Mr. Mousa and others was disgusting. Now the victims and lawyers also want a public inquiry...

I've read somewhere that the Human Rights Act covers embassies and consulates which include prisons overseas directly under Brit control.
 

Latest Threads