Field telephones

Discussion in 'Royal Signals' started by EX_STAB, Feb 24, 2007.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. EX_STAB

    EX_STAB LE

    I need a pair of field telephones for use on civvy rifle ranges.

    Can anyone indicate what the merits of the PTC 405 telephone (the one in it's own box)
    [​IMG]

    are compared with the PTC 404 (the one in a satchel)

    [​IMG]

    Both seem to be similar money on ebay.
     
  2. GLESGA-NED

    GLESGA-NED Guest

    Makes no difference mate. both are phones
     
  3. Lance_Jacked

    Lance_Jacked Old-Salt

    Save some money, when your in the Butts and wish to attract the attention of people on the fire points, stick your head over the parapet and wave....... LOL
     
  4. Jimima_Shark

    Jimima_Shark War Hero

    The key difference between them was length of line (cable) they could work over, no doubt a liney on here will be able to find out what the exact distances are. Unless you're doing some really long distance sniper shooting either will fit your needs. Other than that one's in a box the other is in a satchel.

    Hope that helps.

    Jimima
     
  5. Disco

    Disco LE

    Used with the Field Exchange you can get up to 15k`s out of them on D10.

    The difference is features and usage. The 405 is mechanical unlike the 404 and lacks features like whisper and a silenced ringer with light which the 404 has.

    If your in a hut then get the 405 as it will sit nicely on the desk and is easier to use. The 404 has a b1tch of a ringer button which is tricky to operate especially in the cold. However if your in a ditch or wet enviroment then get the 404.

    Hope that sheds some light on it.
     
  6. Spanish_Dave

    Spanish_Dave LE Good Egg (charities)

    vodaphone et al :numberone:
     
  7. whistler

    whistler War Hero

    One other thing possibly worth considering. The 404s are made of plastic and break easily.

    I remember the linies complaining when they replaced the previous metal ones that they couldn't chuck them about as much.
     
  8. Get a 250. Proper phone.
     
  9. Bigt116

    Bigt116 Swinger

    Have to agree with the above, the 250 is a good sturdy phone with all that you need for the range. and possibly as an older model it may even be cheaper
     
  10. EX_STAB

    EX_STAB LE

    I've sorted the immediate problem with some hired radios but further contributions are still welcome.

    What is the advantage of the 250? Is it nothing more than the tough case?
     
  11. Disco

    Disco LE

    The 250 is a museum piece. It has a quaint ringer handle setup like the old Meggars :thumright: Again it is a mechanical phone like the 405 but it is a full telephone with dial, this was replaced by the 450 (same as the 405 but with dial and CB/LB select. I think I still have one knocking around somewhere!

    [​IMG]
     
  12. EX_STAB

    EX_STAB LE

    Now then,
    reading between the lines here (no pun intended) am I right in thinking that the 405 (in a plastic box) is a mechanical phone like the older 205 and works without batteries but the 404 (in a satchel) needs a power supply - D-cells from memory?

    If it's a bone question forgive me, it's not my speciality.
     
  13. Disco

    Disco LE

    Sorry when I said mechanical I meant a magneto phone with working parts. However both the 404 and 405 are solid state phone using integrated circuits, I keep thinking its the 450!

    The 250 had a winder to provide power. The 404 and 405 use 6 batteries to provide the power for speech and the ringer circuit.

    The 405 is easier to fix if broken (if you have spares) the 404 gets thrown in the bin!!

    Sorry for the confusion
     
  14. HE117

    HE117 LE

    Frankly I have given up with using phones on gallery ranges...

    The bl**dy wires are aways broken and you have to keep someone sitting by the 'dam things....

    When you can buy a couple of civvy PRC radios from Maplin for £20 why bother with phones? The all now come with a ring feature so the RCO and Butts officer can keep them in their pockets...

    If you are shooting on a large range complex and need to talk to range control, then the range staff produce the phones.
     
  15. EX_STAB

    EX_STAB LE

    I've seen a lot of failures with cheap radios, we came close to packing up and going home once on one civvy range I used to use. It's not just batteries - some only seem to work line of sight, not helpful in the buts. The big motorola ones are more reliable but are far from cheap.

    800m of D10 can be had for £40-50, It's not necessary to rely on pre-wired points.

    Appreciate all the comments though.