Army Rumour Service

Register a free account today to join our community
Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site, connect with other members through your own private inbox and will receive smaller adverts!

Ethnic Minorities & Women At Dunkirk

I don't dispute that. Certainly the tin trade was flourishing from very early times. I was making the point that this was probably a seasonal trade for Mediterranean vessels because of the dangers and difficulties. Lief Ericson reached America in about 1010 but there wasn't much trade between America and Europe for the next 500 years!

With regard to the tin trade, Cornish Tin was transported by ship to Britanny (Morlaix for example) and then by pack horse or cart across France to Marseilles.
 
Time for an update I think.

Just to show how far things have fallen a US university now asks students in their Theology class to write about gender criticism and feminism regarding images of Christ. Apparently the spear is a sign of emasculation and gender is a social construct.

Wtf this bullshyt has to do with Theology is anyone's guess. It's identity politics in the classroom.

Jordan Peterson et al has made it quite clear that this is happening and that it's a load of crap. I don't think anyone could possibly deny that nowadays there is a massive agenda within the education system and especially the humanities.
 
Time for an update I think.

Just to show how far things have fallen a US university now asks students in their Theology class to write about gender criticism and feminism regarding images of Christ. Apparently the spear is a sign of emasculation and gender is a social construct.

Wtf this bullshyt has to do with Theology is anyone's guess. It's identity politics in the classroom.

Jordan Peterson et al has made it quite clear that this is happening and that it's a load of crap. I don't think anyone could possibly deny that nowadays there is a massive agenda within the education system and especially the humanities.
Theology is a made up nonsense; it’s hardly surprising that it’s practitioners are prone to other fads and fantasies.
 
I'm not surprised. If you saw a Roman carrying one, it was generally a sign that you were about to be emasculated.
1603965715892.png
Et non amant eam...
 
I see the new Call of Duty trailer depicts a black British paratrooper from WW2 as one of the main characters.

Now fair enough, there was a para called Sidney Cornell who was mixed race (can I still say that?) as his father was black, but suggesting there were black paras in WW2 as the norm is a bit disingenuous.

1632326127209.png


That would be 1 in something like 20,000.

Naturally, the plebs who have never read a book will take this all in as gospel. The re writing of history is now being done by video games.
 
It's well known the first thing they did on the drop zone at Arnhem was set up a steel drum band and start cooking up compo rice and peas while waiting for the glider carnival floats to land.
 
I see the new Call of Duty trailer depicts a black British paratrooper from WW2 as one of the main characters.

Now fair enough, there was a para called Sidney Cornell who was mixed race (can I still say that?) as his father was black, but suggesting there were black paras in WW2 as the norm is a bit disingenuous.

View attachment 605896

That would be 1 in something like 20,000.

Naturally, the plebs who have never read a book will take this all in as gospel. The re writing of history is now being done by video games.
I have to say he looks a bit like Andi Peters…
 
I see the new Call of Duty trailer depicts a black British paratrooper from WW2 as one of the main characters.

Now fair enough, there was a para called Sidney Cornell who was mixed race (can I still say that?) as his father was black, but suggesting there were black paras in WW2 as the norm is a bit disingenuous.



That would be 1 in something like 20,000.

Naturally, the plebs who have never read a book will take this all in as gospel. The re writing of history is now being done by video games.
Sgt Cornell was part of the 7th Parachutist Battalion. Of its 300 men he was one of just three black soldiers.
image.jpg

 
I see the new Call of Duty trailer depicts a black British paratrooper from WW2 as one of the main characters.

Now fair enough, there was a para called Sidney Cornell who was mixed race (can I still say that?) as his father was black, but suggesting there were black paras in WW2 as the norm is a bit disingenuous.

View attachment 605896

That would be 1 in something like 20,000.

Naturally, the plebs who have never read a book will take this all in as gospel. The re writing of history is now being done by video games.

If the CO isn't a non-binary POC, it'll just reinforce the patriarchy's institutional racism.
 
There's quite a tiff going on over in the Land of the Free that the Dunkirk movie doesn't have enough minorities or women in it.

‘Dunkirk’ review in USA Today warns ‘no lead actors of color’ in WWII-inspired film

At first I thought they were sucking up to the liberal lefties and trying to re-write our glorious history, but after a little bit of research I'm wondering if they might have a point.

To my surprise Indian troops were at Dunkirk as part of a mule logistics train.

The Royal Indian Army Service Corps » Dunkirk 1940 - The Before, The Reality, The Aftermath

View attachment 289977


View attachment 289978


Unfortunately the story goes that they were captured by the Germans before escaping, but according to this story a few of them were saved by the father of Paddy Ashdown.

Ashdown tells how father stood by Indian troops

"Sir Paddy Ashdown revealed yesterday how his father was brought before a court martial for refusing to comply with an order to abandon Indian troops under his command during the Dunkirk retreat.

The order had been "idiotic and disgraceful", said Sir Paddy, who was a Royal Marine captain before he was leader of the Liberal Democrats. His father, who ended the war a colonel, was in the Royal Indian Army Service Corps, based in the Punjab. In 1939 he took a platoon of Indian soldiers and their troop of mules as one of four mule trains to join the British Expeditionary Force in France.



During the BEF's 100-mile retreat in June 1940, the order went out from a senior British officer to set loose the mules and the Indians; the British officers were ordered to make their way to Dunkirk for evacuation, since officers were in short supply.


Sir Paddy's father, John, disobeyed, turning loose the mules but marching his platoon to Dunkirk without loss. There he secured a berth for them all on the last ship out before the jetty was bombed. Back in England, he was reunited with his wife, Lois, but court martialled for disobeying an order. The court martial was subsequently thrown out, according to Sir Paddy.


The Ministry of Defence, when first approached about the story by the Southall-based TV company Zee TV, said its archive department had after two days been unable to find any record of Indian troops at Dunkirk; it also reported it had lost the records of Indian Army court martials. Zee TV located a record of the Indian troops' presence in hours at the Imperial War Museum. The ministry then asserted that the command to cut loose the Indians and mules, made by a single officer, did not amount to an official order.


Sir Paddy said last night: "It may seem that the order was a racist one in the context of our time, but my father thought simply that these were his men, he was responsible for them, and he must bring them back. That was the beginning and the end of it."


I've never heard of any ethnic minority troops being at Dunkirk so I'm pleased to stand corrected, perhaps the movie should have included a few just to make a point that we didn't stand alone? If they were there they also deserve to have their story told.

Does anyone else know of any other parts of British history which weren't 'whiter than white'?

I've always found it rather interesting that if you go to Trafalgar Square and look at the picture at the bottom of the coloumn there's a black chap on the far left.

View attachment 289980

~DC

Morning @Dashing_Chap,
From one of the local 'comics' recently.
Screenshot_20210923-121843_Photos~2.jpg
Screenshot_20210923-121852_Photos~2.jpg
 
Top