Did Argentina drop napalm on there own dead??

Plenty of long time Arrsers here (and over on RR too) with experience of the conflict or the FI or who are skilled and experienced researchers and historians.
Despite being a (not so) humble Int Corps Lance Jack at the time I was privy to a lot high level stuff at one of the Bde HQs and the MoD. I also got to know the guys who were in the Marine Bde HQ and TF HQs. I still get together with some of my old mates from those days for an annual piss up. Guess what - my old mates also have their contacts with other ex-Int types.

Now, the Int Corps can be a very incestuous old boys club - back in the day everyone pretty much knew, or had heard of, everyone else. In addition, many of us went on to bigger and better things - working with unusual units, high level postings at senior levels - you get my drift. Add to this the Corps fetish for gossip, rumour and finding out interesting stuff you weren't meant to know about and you have an organisation that would certainly have known about these sort of alledged incidents. Let's face it, if there had been any juicy stuff hidden away we would have been the ones to find out about it.

I would have though that the chaps who interrogated Menendez might have come up with something at least (apart from nicking confiscating his private letters) but no...

I have never, ever heard that any of these rumours and gossip are actually true. They are simply gossip and rumours...

I'm getting together with my old mates next month for a day on the piss - after a few beers I reckon we could invent a new conspiracy theory... ;-)
 
...And as for being able to set hordes of former Bootnecks on another Civvy to duff him up? The bloke needs to take his head for a shit.
I didn't get as far as that bit, having given up giggling like a loon after the first three or four lines of shit splattered wibble, but that is comedy gold.
 
Despite being a (not so) humble Int Corps Lance Jack at the time I was privy to a lot high level stuff at one of the Bde HQs and the MoD. I also got to know the guys who were in the Marine Bde HQ and TF HQs. I still get together with some of my old mates from those days for an annual piss up. Guess what - my old mates also have their contacts with other ex-Int types.

Now, the Int Corps can be a very incestuous old boys club - back in the day everyone pretty much knew, or had heard of, everyone else. In addition, many of us went on to bigger and better things - working with unusual units, high level postings at senior levels - you get my drift. Add to this the Corps fetish for gossip, rumour and finding out interesting stuff you weren't meant to know about and you have an organisation that would certainly have known about these sort of alledged incidents. Let's face it, if there had been any juicy stuff hidden away we would have been the ones to find out about it.

I would have though that the chaps who interrogated Menendez might have come up with something at least (apart from nicking confiscating his private letters) but no...

I have never, ever heard that any of these rumours and gossip are actually true. They are simply gossip and rumours...

I'm getting together with my old mates next month for a day on the piss - after a few beers I reckon we could invent a new conspiracy theory... ;-)
One of the chaps who interrogated Menendez was on the FI study period I was on. I didn’t get to talk to him much but he never mentioned anything in his talk about it.
 
George, you lost an argument on Quora, that's the origins of this, and to prove it, you went and deleted every single reply I made to your thread, so nobody could see. You then embarked upon a six month hate campaign of spreading a complete lie about me, with clever trolling, all out of this obsessive bitterness. And yes George, it is utterly obsessive.
You have based your "knowledge" on a book you haven't read, yet have told everyone all about it for six months... if I spent six months wailing about a book and it turned out I hadn't even read the thing, my credibility would be zero... and not just me, but anyone. Yet you seem to think this is normal or acceptable. In fact, if I showed here the extent of your obsessive behaviour around me, they'd agree that it is far from normal. It is obsessive and downright creepy. You're into "single white female" territory with this... You really need a hobby or a job. Your constant wailing about your "Academic" credentials hasn't helped you into employment, has it?
Know where I am George? Inverness, working. Yesterday at Skye, working. It would be recommended that you join the real world and stop playing with computers.
Now let me ask you what you ever did, other than pour scorn on what others have done? What have you achieved? What have you done which makes you feel superior to others? At least I've gone out and done something, and despite your"claims" (about a book you never read) you have actually just sat behind a myriad of fake profiles making stuff up, lying about me, projecting, agreeing with yourself and trying to convince others... all because you lost an argument on Quora. It ain't normal behaviour.
If you don't stop this, I will take legal action and I will put you on the stand and you will lose in public. Because you're destroying reputations and you're actually stalking me now. You won't stand there when you can't hide behind a computer screen to invent utter lies about people, will you? And I'll show everyone that you are a libellous troll. You are wasting my time and everyone's with this obsessive fantasy and making up ridiculous stories about things which simply didn't happen. And I'll give you that you do a convincing job, but you're a fraud and a charlatan, claiming to "know" things about a book you never read and a conference you weren't at. Every word you have written from your fake profiles is utter crap, and you know it is too. Now I'm a great friend to our veterans, and I'm the guy who was there for our Royals when nobody else was. I said no to writing First Casualty three times George, because I said someone might do a better job and I didn't want to get it wrong... The Royals said everyone had had 35 bloody years and hadn't got it right once yet. Now they say it's perfect. I had one literally crying on me a few weeks back, thanking me that his grandkids will never read those lies about him again, and if you were in the UK, not tucked behind a screen in Australia grinning at your latest clever lie, you'd have sixty bootnecks kicking your door in. Has anyone here actually asked them? Not one person.
You are a stalker and fantasist, and you have projected that onto me, George. I'll speak to the veterans, but the fact that you're here is sad, and worse because I've had to read comments from people you've taken in with this obsessive farce about a character you've created which you pretend is me. When I'm back from the Highlands, I'll happily show them what a liar you are, and until then, be warned, if you continue, I will sue you for my name and reputation and I will show you up publicly.
Please Ricky, do produce your ‘evidence’ on this lost argument, between you. I am convinced everybody on the thread, would be delighted to read it. The events I have described from the conference, are very accurate, corroborated by another attendee’s blog on the same matter. Often, it seems, you declare you will present ‘evidence’, yet this ‘evidence’ never surfaces. Why is that?
 
George, you lost an argument on Quora, that's the origins of this, and to prove it, you went and deleted every single reply I made to your thread, so nobody could see. You then embarked upon a six month hate campaign of spreading a complete lie about me, with clever trolling, all out of this obsessive bitterness. And yes George, it is utterly obsessive.
You have based your "knowledge" on a book you haven't read, yet have told everyone all about it for six months... if I spent six months wailing about a book and it turned out I hadn't even read the thing, my credibility would be zero... and not just me, but anyone. Yet you seem to think this is normal or acceptable. In fact, if I showed here the extent of your obsessive behaviour around me, they'd agree that it is far from normal. It is obsessive and downright creepy. You're into "single white female" territory with this... You really need a hobby or a job. Your constant wailing about your "Academic" credentials hasn't helped you into employment, has it?
Know where I am George? Inverness, working. Yesterday at Skye, working. It would be recommended that you join the real world and stop playing with computers.
Now let me ask you what you ever did, other than pour scorn on what others have done? What have you achieved? What have you done which makes you feel superior to others? At least I've gone out and done something, and despite your"claims" (about a book you never read) you have actually just sat behind a myriad of fake profiles making stuff up, lying about me, projecting, agreeing with yourself and trying to convince others... all because you lost an argument on Quora. It ain't normal behaviour.
If you don't stop this, I will take legal action and I will put you on the stand and you will lose in public. Because you're destroying reputations and you're actually stalking me now. You won't stand there when you can't hide behind a computer screen to invent utter lies about people, will you? And I'll show everyone that you are a libellous troll. You are wasting my time and everyone's with this obsessive fantasy and making up ridiculous stories about things which simply didn't happen. And I'll give you that you do a convincing job, but you're a fraud and a charlatan, claiming to "know" things about a book you never read and a conference you weren't at. Every word you have written from your fake profiles is utter crap, and you know it is too. Now I'm a great friend to our veterans, and I'm the guy who was there for our Royals when nobody else was. I said no to writing First Casualty three times George, because I said someone might do a better job and I didn't want to get it wrong... The Royals said everyone had had 35 bloody years and hadn't got it right once yet. Now they say it's perfect. I had one literally crying on me a few weeks back, thanking me that his grandkids will never read those lies about him again, and if you were in the UK, not tucked behind a screen in Australia grinning at your latest clever lie, you'd have sixty bootnecks kicking your door in. Has anyone here actually asked them? Not one person.
You are a stalker and fantasist, and you have projected that onto me, George. I'll speak to the veterans, but the fact that you're here is sad, and worse because I've had to read comments from people you've taken in with this obsessive farce about a character you've created which you pretend is me. When I'm back from the Highlands, I'll happily show them what a liar you are, and until then, be warned, if you continue, I will sue you for my name and reputation and I will show you up publicly.
I would suggest you go and look at how things ended for David Irving when he tried that same tactic to silence his critics.
 
Don't know if this page has already been mentioned, but it is fairly damning of RDP as a "historian". Seems to sum up pretty well what just about everyone on here has been saying.....

Ricky D Phillips is not a Historian
Just reiterating the point that Phillips' bete noir was only introduced into the thread a full 13 pages in.

So much for us all being trolled into disbelieving RDP. I think our minds were rather made up before then.

There's an interesting challenge to his Amtrac and LCI theories (a quora link in the comments below the link in the post). Worth a read.
 
I fear Ricky may well be right, he may have earned a stalker, although not in George, but me. See below screenshots taken seconds ago, plus the link to the article in case he tries to change it before people read it... he was a soldier, apparently (or at least should have been ). Walt...
 
George, you lost an argument on Quora, that's the origins of this, and to prove it, you went and deleted every single reply I made to your thread, so nobody could see. You then embarked upon a six month hate campaign of spreading a complete lie about me, with clever trolling, all out of this obsessive bitterness. And yes George, it is utterly obsessive.
You have based your "knowledge" on a book you haven't read, yet have told everyone all about it for six months... if I spent six months wailing about a book and it turned out I hadn't even read the thing, my credibility would be zero... and not just me, but anyone. Yet you seem to think this is normal or acceptable. In fact, if I showed here the extent of your obsessive behaviour around me, they'd agree that it is far from normal. It is obsessive and downright creepy. You're into "single white female" territory with this... You really need a hobby or a job. Your constant wailing about your "Academic" credentials hasn't helped you into employment, has it?
Know where I am George? Inverness, working. Yesterday at Skye, working. It would be recommended that you join the real world and stop playing with computers.
Now let me ask you what you ever did, other than pour scorn on what others have done? What have you achieved? What have you done which makes you feel superior to others? At least I've gone out and done something, and despite your"claims" (about a book you never read) you have actually just sat behind a myriad of fake profiles making stuff up, lying about me, projecting, agreeing with yourself and trying to convince others... all because you lost an argument on Quora. It ain't normal behaviour.
If you don't stop this, I will take legal action and I will put you on the stand and you will lose in public. Because you're destroying reputations and you're actually stalking me now. You won't stand there when you can't hide behind a computer screen to invent utter lies about people, will you? And I'll show everyone that you are a libellous troll. You are wasting my time and everyone's with this obsessive fantasy and making up ridiculous stories about things which simply didn't happen. And I'll give you that you do a convincing job, but you're a fraud and a charlatan, claiming to "know" things about a book you never read and a conference you weren't at. Every word you have written from your fake profiles is utter crap, and you know it is too. Now I'm a great friend to our veterans, and I'm the guy who was there for our Royals when nobody else was. I said no to writing First Casualty three times George, because I said someone might do a better job and I didn't want to get it wrong... The Royals said everyone had had 35 bloody years and hadn't got it right once yet. Now they say it's perfect. I had one literally crying on me a few weeks back, thanking me that his grandkids will never read those lies about him again, and if you were in the UK, not tucked behind a screen in Australia grinning at your latest clever lie, you'd have sixty bootnecks kicking your door in. Has anyone here actually asked them? Not one person.
You are a stalker and fantasist, and you have projected that onto me, George. I'll speak to the veterans, but the fact that you're here is sad, and worse because I've had to read comments from people you've taken in with this obsessive farce about a character you've created which you pretend is me. When I'm back from the Highlands, I'll happily show them what a liar you are, and until then, be warned, if you continue, I will sue you for my name and reputation and I will show you up publicly.
^
Local offy shut. On the terps.
 
Don't know if this page has already been mentioned, but it is fairly damning of RDP as a "historian". Seems to sum up pretty well what just about everyone on here has been saying.....

Ricky D Phillips is not a Historian
After reading that, I wonder if Bugsy and Ricky are ever seen in the same room together! Remarkably similar MO's.
 
I fear Ricky may well be right, he may have earned a stalker, although not in George, but me. See below screenshots taken seconds ago, plus the link to the article in case he tries to change it before people read it... he was a soldier, apparently (or at least should have been ). Walt...
That's a serious accusation... I have never claimed to have been a soldier. So you claim you're not George, but aren't honest enough to say who you are? Why not? I'm here as me... who are you? You pretend honesty from behind a fake profile and think you're credible? You're a liar. Tell people who you are then....
 
That's a serious accusation... I have never claimed to have been a soldier. So you claim you're not George, but aren't honest enough to say who you are? Why not? I'm here as me... who are you? You pretend honesty from behind a fake profile and think you're credible? You're a liar. Tell people who you are then....
So the pages of bio attached by BH aren’t yours then? The ones that clearly claim you were injured, which ‘ended your selection training with the British Army’?
 
So the pages of bio attached by BH aren’t yours then? The ones that clearly claim you were injured, which ‘ended your selection training with the British Army’?
If you read it carefully he was in the process of his application to the REME but following an injury this process ended. I would question how a BTEC and NVQ are half a degree each as I have both and they only got me points towards my CertEd.
 

Similar threads


Latest Threads

Top