Desecration of Graves

Discussion in 'The Intelligence Cell' started by spasticus, Sep 22, 2011.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. Ok I know this is Navy but thought it might be of interest. Copied from the Mortimer group on facebook.

    Two Dutch salvage ships are desecrating the wrecks of HMS Cressy, Hogue and Aboukir, sunk in 1914 in the North Sea looking for copper and bronze. The issue is complicated because the MOD seems to have sold the wrecks to a salvor in the 1950's. However a group of Dutch divers are organising a petition to get the salavage stopped and the wrecks treated with respect as the wargraves and important parts of the marine environment that they are.

    Mortimer says please sign the petition It is in Dutch but is easy to understand. This is an International issue- these could be the sailors or service people of any nation
  2. Wordsmith

    Wordsmith LE Book Reviewer


    Here's some basic info about the sinkings:

    Loss of HMS Aboukir, HMS Cressy and HMS Hogue

    Before the sinking some at the Admiralty didn't take the submarine threat seriously enough.

    Here's some info on the current state of the ships.

    Q & A Wrecks August 2004 - Divernet

    The items mentioned would have contained copper alloys of varying descriptions - particularly the propellers. They've got a significant value with the present values in the commodity markets.

    But it is remarkably distasteful to salvage from war graves. The ships went down quickly with men trapped below decks, so the hulks will almost certainly still contain human remains.

  3. in_the_cheapseats

    in_the_cheapseats LE Moderator

    I agree with the distasteful part but I'd also say the case for reestablishing them as war graves 60 years after our own government has sold them on and they have already been subject to "heavy salvage" somewhat weakens the argument here.
  4. When does grave desecration/robbing become archeology?

    Is it just a function of time only and if so how long has to pass before it becomes ok?
    • Like Like x 2
  5. TheIronDuke

    TheIronDuke LE Book Reviewer

    Sorry, let me get this straight? RN flogged the wrecks containing their dead in the 1950's. The salvors then blew the sterns off to recover the propellers and shafts. Midship sections were opened with explosives to reach the condensers and in the bows the torpedo tubes have been blown out.

    And now a bunch of Cloggie divers are getting their smalls in a bunch about respecting our dead? Our glorious dead have been blown to dust for 50 years or more judging by the evidence.

    Not signing.
  6. ...........and the victor of this action is commeorated in a barracks in his home city of Herford and has been home to a BAOR unit for most of the last 70 years
  7. We've all nicked the odd skull from RN wrecks to adorn our gothic style armchairs. No harm done.
    • Like Like x 1

    FORMER_FYRDMAN LE Book Reviewer

    All true, but still not an argument for a wrong to be perpetuated.
  9. Sign it or I'll cut off the electric current to your nipple clamps. RN should be ashamed of themselves. Even more so.
  10. Signed. Of course, the MoD should really give the cloggies their money back.
  11. Harewood isn't a boxhead name...

    Interesting note, 9/12 Lancers were teh first and the Last unit to be housed in the barracks (excluding ints current encumbants the Sgts Mess singlies of 1 Div and Sig Regt and the vehicles of 211 and 212 Sig Sqns (part of 1 ADSR).
  12. ...Weddigen Kaserne is though!

    There used to be a plaque on the house in Petersliestrasse to Otto Weddigen.

    The Stadt Herfore had a huge painting of the sinking of the Cressey Hougue and Aboukir in storage with other paintings that cannot be exhibited for one reason or another. I had the miosfortune to be the property member for the Wentworth officers Mess after it had been rebuilt after a fire in 12986(?) I managed to get permission from the stadt to borrow the painting to hang on a bare wall in the dining hall at Wentworth. Unless you kneww the story it would look just like a big naval battle and not arouse any comment. But useful if and when any visiting naval chappie made "senior service" remarks. I left the Army before it happened and my successor might not have followed through with the idea.
  13. Anyone know if the NAAFI complex has a name? It houses the pads naafi and the youth service at the mo (IIRC).