Dead Men Risen: The death of Lieutenant Mark Evison

Discussion in 'The Intelligence Cell' started by SOLO, Mar 14, 2011.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. Dead Men Risen: The death of Lieutenant Mark Evison - Telegraph

    ..'leading 15 of his men, plus four Afghan soldiers and an interpreterstruggling to get a proper signal on his Bowman radio in the middle of a firefight near Checkpoint Haji Alem'

    8.46am, May 9th initial casualty report 'category C’
    7 minutes later it was received at Brigade Headquarters
    3 minutes later upgraded ‘Category B’, sent - failed to get through or was not passed up the chain of command
    9am Apache on station 8 minutes after it had been called for pilot would not open fire because he feared killing civilians
    34 minutes to extract casualty 450 metres to FOB
    9.09am Chinook tasked, but it was too big to land inside
    9.25 am, it was cancelled and a pair of American Pedro Black Hawks tasked instead
    9.29am, two Pedro Black Hawks took off from Camp Bastion
    Casualty experiencing massive bleeding for 49 minutes
    9.39am final member of patrol back in FOB
    9.47am Pedro made a ‘hot landing’ under Taliban fire another hovered firing 30mm rounds into enemy positions
    33 seconds later lifted off
    14 minutes to get back to Camp Bastion
    10.03am casualty in operating theatre
    1:23 minutes time from casualty being shot to arriving in Camp Bastion well outside the ‘golden hour’
    3.55am local time pupils became fixed and dilated and a scan indicated he was brain dead
    Casualty flown back to Selly Oak hospital in Birmingham, treatment book recorded details of more than 30 pints of blood
    10.23am on 12 May parents turned off their son’s life-support machine

    There was no helicopter available to take his close from his patrol base to Camp Bastion to bid farewell in Camp Bastion

    At his inquest, however, the coroner was later to state he probably would have died despite the inexplicable helicopter delay.
  2. Dead Men Risen: Major Sean Birchall and the 'Afghan factor' - Telegraph

    Apparently the MoD spent £150,000 of tax payers bunce on buying up the whole of the first print run of this book! They then had them pulped, which, we were told, took about 7 hours. 50 words were changed in the manuscript and it was then re-published - I heard the author discussing it on Radio 4 this morning on the way to work. ****ing extraordinary.

    Dead Men Risen: The real reasons why the MoD wanted to stop my book – Telegraph Blogs

    Dead Men Risen: The Welsh Guards and the Real Story of Britain's War in Afghanistan: Toby Harnden: Books
  3. Yep, I wonder if the unedited original version might end up on the net somewhere....
  4. jim24

    jim24 Book Reviewer

    We have been trying to get one for over a week but Toby and the publishers are tied into a very hard confidentiality agreement with the MOD, the ARRSE book club has been trying hard on your behalf, I'm hoping to have a meeting with Toby later this week I might have to revert to alcohol and see what I can blag
  5. With only 50 words changed, it might be difficult to spot the difference!

    From TH's account in the Spectator, it looks as though the MoD will be bearing a grudge over this for some time!

    "If the preoccupation with a gagging clause was an indication of the MoD’s priorities, then their deletion of a line in the settlement agreement made clear their feelings. An undertaking to deal with Quercus and the author ‘on a fair and transparent basis’ in the future was unacceptable to the MoD. Well, at least there was some honesty and consistency in that."

    Pulped by the MoD | The Spectator
  6. jim24

    jim24 Book Reviewer

  7. In other words you want to try and blag a book to put out details which the MOD is clear will not only put our own troops at risk, but could also risk UK international relations and cause major problems for a lot of people.

    In what possible way does this help support the troops? I've seen editing processes for other books and its not about CYA, its about protecting national security to safeguard people on the front line. Its done by experienced forces people who know what they are talking about.

    Why do you want to put people on the front line at risk? What do you think will be achieved by this?
  8. jim24

    jim24 Book Reviewer

    the book club actually had the story before the Spectator

  9. The MoD approved the book initially and then asked Quercus to pull it at the last moment. TH's point is that that anything relevant to OPSEC was removed for the first run. The implication is that the major rewrite requested by the MoD at the last moment was more to do with saving political embarrassment about an under resourced operation.

    TH's note in the Telegraph left me with the impression that the excerpts that were previewed in the Telegraph were amongst those that the MoD wanted removed.
  10. Because after almost a decade at war, hardware availability and suitability is still an issue.
  11. jim24

    jim24 Book Reviewer

    If anything it has only been pulped to to save the face of the lying cnut who lied in the house of commons, got nothing to do with troops safety only saving Gordon Browns Arse for telling lies and causing the deaths of better men the him the cnut
  12. jim24

    jim24 Book Reviewer

    The Book was pulped for political reasons, and F@ck all else, nothing to do with security
  13. Contrast and compare with wikileaks?
  14. Listen to the article on the Radio this morning: BBC iPlayer - Today: 14/03/2011 and scroll forward to the 2hr 16 minute 34 second mark.

    Apparently the pulping was done so the Estonians wouldn't get a cob on!
  15. There is none.