Convoy Escort Programme

Discussion in 'Current Affairs, News and Analysis' started by smallbrownprivates, Feb 18, 2011.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. In the times today (and behind the pay wall online), Jardine Thompson's "private navy" gets a good spread.

    London insurers' private fleet to fight Somali pirates
    Miles Costello From: The Times February 18, 2011 9:24AM Increase Text SizeDecrease Text SizePrintEmail Share
    INSURERS in the City of London are finalising plans to set up a private fleet of armed patrol boats in the Gulf of Aden, in a new drive to stamp out Somali piracy.
    The naval protection force was conceived by leading figures in the Lloyd's of London market. They have been working with ship owners, freight operators and governments for months, marshalling support for their plan.

    The goal of the Convoy Escort Programme is to provide protection for tankers trying to navigate the seas off war-torn Somalia while also reducing the soaring costs of insuring vessels, cargo and crews against increasingly vicious attacks by pirates.

    Key representatives of the shipping industry, including the Baltic and International Maritime Council (Bimco) have agreed to explore the idea further. Giles Noakes, the chief maritime security officer of Bimco, said that he would be briefing American politicians in Washington on the plan next week.

    It is understood that the industry-led project is being monitored by the Royal Navy and its counterparts. The Times understands that the Navy would regard the escorts as a trial which, if successful, would allow naval vessels to hunt pirates in other areas. If the fleet can secure funding and win the support of the shipping community, it could be up and running within six months. There are also plans to explore using former Nimrod maritime patrol air crews to provide aerial surveillance.

    Success for the venture, which has tried to shun the "private navy" tag, would mark a gear change in international efforts to clamp down on piracy. Despite a successful recent intervention by the Royal Navy, the pirates have escalated their activities sharply in the past fortnight, seizing an oil tanker and its 125 million-pound cargo and killing two of its Filipino crew.

    Under the plan, which has been developed over two years, a non-profit association involving private and public sector members would be set up. It would control a fleet of 18 vessels, each with a fixed gun position and an armed crew authorised to engage the pirates in battle.

    Each vessel would carry eight armed security personnel and four additional crew as well as inflatable speedboats, known as "Ribs", which could be dispatched into combat if the tankers they were protecting came under attack.

    Although it would be managed separately, the fleet would be under the operational control of the relevant national navy and the crew would have to conform to international rules on combat and engagement.

    One of the key architects of the CEP is Sean Woollerson, a partner in the marine, oil and gas division at Jardine Lloyd Thompson, a leading Lloyd's broker for companies seeking insurance protection, particularly for war risks and kidnap and ransom. KLT is organising the fleet through BGN Risk, a global security consultancy.

    Mr Woollerson estimates that the programme would need about $US27.5 million to pay for 18 second-hand vessels, believed to be Swedish patrol boats. It is understood that the plan is to try to tap a $US200 million anti-piracy fund managed by the EU.

    "It has taken an extraordinary amount of hard work and effort over the past two years, but we hope we're about 70 per cent of the way there," Mr Woollerson told The Times.

    JLT has been working on the project with insurance underwriters, including at Ascot Underwriting, another leading Lloyd's insurer.

    Mr Woollerson said that the association would draw its members from shipping associations, charterers, oil companies, insurance underwriters, lawyers, governments and navies. With a rotating chairman, expected to be elected from among international ship-owning companies, it would have its own chief executive and management team. In theory, any ship seeking the protection of the fleet on a trip through the Gulf of Aden would be able to do so through her Lloyd's of London broker, Mr Woollerson said.
    "

    Talking to colleagues who are involved in MarSec, some have used the phrase "Conscience Money" as the $27M is a fraction of what insurers have reaped from insurance premiums since 2008.

    $27M seems a little on the low side to purchase vessels and as well as to run them for 2 years. The stated aim in a sidebar of the times article is to escort 460 vessels a week means they are looking at covering 20,000 vessels a year, or most of the annual GoA traffic.

    Then again if 18 privately purchased vessels on a limited budget can apparently replace or do better what over 70 international naval vessels supported by a number of larger defence budgets are doing, then maybe privatisation is the way forward!
     
  2. Fascinating
     
  3. Grumblegrunt

    Grumblegrunt LE Book Reviewer

    is that the aden based private navy to battle pirates?

    while I fear a shoot first policy ala blackwater I do actually approve of the concept and they should let the navies out there cast pirates adrift or treat them like did in the good ole days where you sunk their boats and let them drown.
     
  4. Much of initial post missing. Tapatalk for BB has some limitations.
    When online properly, have linky
     
  5. jim24

    jim24 Book Reviewer

  6. Basically, the insurers and shippers are getting pissed off with the namby pamby kid glove way governments are dealing with pirates and trying to force their hand into adopting a more robust posture.

    The only way piracy will be contained is if the risk/reward equation for the pirates gets too painful. At the moment, piracy is a zero risk, high reward occupation.
     
  7. makes for intresting reading thanks
     
  8. Basically, the Somali maritime venture capitalists are getting pissed off with the namby pamby kid glove way governments are dealing with criminal bankers and trying to force their hand into adopting a more robust posture.

    The only way financial criminality will be contained is if the risk/reward equation for the City pirates gets too painful. At the moment, fraudulent banking is a zero risk, high reward occupation.
     
  9. The risk/reward equation works both ways. IIRC convoys were proposed when anti-piracy patrols were first introduced in the area. Ship owners rejected the idea because it costs $100,000 a day for their super tanker full of crude to hang around waiting for the convoy to form up and then proceeding at the speed of the slowest vessel.

    It will be interesting to see whether this new scheme is more successful. Perhaps they'll have enough escorts to maintain safe channels that are free of pirates rather than trying to protect isolated groups of ships. Wouldn't fancy taking on armed nutters from a RIB though.

    Whatever happened to Blackwater's cunning plan? I heard they'd bought a knackered old trawler with a view to tarting it up and sending it out to the Red Sea to civilize the locals. Did it sink under the weight of back issues of Soldier of Fortune the crew tried to bring aboard?
     
  10. It could only be a matter of time. Governments are not willing commit resources and risk political fall out from its armed forces killing pirates.

    So this way the pirates encounter an unfortunate accident at sea. The freighters/tankers go about their business unmolested.

    Everyone's a winner. Except the pirates their dead, but they will be commemorated in a hard hitting joint investigation by the Guardian and the BBC about ex British service personnel killing innocent Somali fishermen who whilst admittedly being in possession of RPGs and AK47s they had absolutely no intention of hijacking that tanker no Sir they was innocent.
     
  11. the_boy_syrup

    the_boy_syrup LE Book Reviewer

    Why not send in a couple opf god old fashioned Q ships
    Potter about and then hand out a good kicking just at the right time
     
  12. It would be cheaper to hire the Russian Navy, and much easier RoE Pirate ship spotted - Shot - Sink.
     
  13. Or, alternatively, the pirates simply reflag captured vessels under the Red Ensign, thus guaranteeing that the Royal Navy will protect their human right to operate their maritime wealth redistribution programme, even if that means starting a war with the USA.

    Indeed, if their trusty vessel is swamped by a Tsunami, it's hardly their fault, is it? Blokes who have never been to school can hardly be expected to understand complex phrases like "DANGER - LIQUEFIED PETROLEUM GAS" printed in 15 foot high letters on the side of the fleeing merchantman that they're shooting at, can they?

    At least, if they're registered in London, they can float confident that A Royal Navy Lynx will be along soon to pluck them from the sea and into the welcoming arms of Phil Shinner who will have them in a council penthouse near Hyde Park in time for tea, passports and compensation.