This is not the correct place to discus Medical & Staff in Confidence of troops. You never no what journos or other folk may gleam. Thats not the sort of question you should be asking you muppet. Would you like folk discussing you ? No !! Grrrrrrrrr
Why not? I am just hoping that he is doing ok and is back at work - what's wrong with that? Surely JB VC is now in the public domain and most of the civilised world know how he won the VC and got his injuries. So what's wrong with finding out if he is on the mend? Surely a great ad for the army and its ability to rehabilitate our troops? No big secret there - I'm not asking for a copy of hgis last confidential!
I think your comments are a panicked reply - think about it the next time you touch the keyboard
and I'm with the Sex Machine on this one. What's wrong with finding out that one of our own has recovered from his wounds? The award of the VC and his appalling injuries were common knowledge across the media so what's so bad about someone concerned enough to ask how he is getting on? We are supposed to look out for our oppo's so instead of basking in his glory why can't we show some compassion?
Are there any Tigers out there who can shed some light on the situation?
Sorry sex-machine, the enquiry might be genuine, but it sounds suspiciously like a journo trying to source or pad out a story. An open forum is not the place to ask that type of question. Insulting the response of others to what they consider to be an inappropriate question is in itself a response that appears "panicked" (to use your word) which could make others even more suspicious of your motives.
Medical details are and should remain confidential, until the subject of those details chooses to release them (or a coroner does!). Regarding his "being in the public domain", just because he has been on the news does not make any difference to his right to confidentiality.
Why not send a "get well soon" card c/o PWRR, and see if there is any response to that?
Folks - a general 'I hope he's alright' type message is clearly fine, but as several learned ARRSErs have pointed out, posting actual medical details would not only be incredibly stupid, it would also contravene his rights and potentially cause all kinds of issues downrange.
I know I don't have to preach on about this to you guys, but any possibility we could just let this thread whither away quietly...I'm sure everyone on this site wishes all injured soldiers a speedy recovery and a hassle free rehab.
Next to him stood the ramrod figure of Pte Johnson Beharry, 26, scars still visible in his close-cropped hair.
Pte Beharry became the first man to be awarded the VC in 20 years when he was gazetted in 2005 for rescuing colleagues under fire, despite suffering heavy wounds at al-Amarah, Iraq, in 2004.
"It is wonderful for me to be able to listen to the stories of these men," he said, gesturing to the collection of stooped but fiercely proud figures who were busy renewing old comradeships all around him.
"Every man's actions were different and some don't like to talk about them much, but they all say the same thing: they didn't do it on their own," said the Grenada-born soldier who is receiving treatment for wounds he received with the Princess of Wales' Royal Regt.
"I couldn't have done what I did without my boys. I am just sad that they are out there now and I am still here."