Following on from some discussion on the Andy Murray thread I checked the search function and it seems that the last time that Arrsers got excited about this was in 2008 (although there was a thread in 2010 as well). In 2008 the opening post on the thread was from Afghanman who said: "Got to be a close run thing between Chris Hoy and Lewis Hamilton (if he wins the F1 Title) hasn't it? Becky Adlington? Andy Murray has got to be up there too... " Bipolar responded making reference to Murray needing a personality implant. How some things never change! So in 2012 Who should win, and why? Should there be a separate category for men and women? Should paralympians have their own category or be in with the rest?