Afghanistan. This has got to stop!

Discussion in 'The Intelligence Cell' started by banjotrooper, Jun 19, 2008.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. Whils't British soldiers and certain other nations troops are falling like skittles at the moment, I would like to know where and what the Germans, Italians, Belgians and Spanish troops are up to out there? If they are in NATO, THEN FIGHT, NOT COMPLAIN! These combat opt out clauses are just not on. I don't give a shite if it's an popular war! If part of NATO, then surely you shouldn't be able to pick and choose your wars? If these Nations won't take the full burden and stand and fight alongside NATO, then kick the fcukers out of NATO. Time to dissolve NATO I think and the boxheads and their likes can just FRO!
    Their spineless behaviour and up yours NATO attitude is just not acceptable, whilst our fallen troops blood leaches in the desert sands! :x
  2. I hate to break this to you but the Yanks say pretty much the same thing about us...
  3. If that is so, then they are more out of touch with reality than I suspected.
  4. I totally agree with you, what REALLY worries me is this so called Euro Armed forces, we will be in an even worse place, we won't get involved in anything, and if we are threatened then the Euro crats will just to talk their way out of trouble, and we know from history that rarely works

  5. The day i fight alongside a frenchman is the day it's all gone to pot.
  6. Don't get me wrong, im all for more cooperation between nations, like lusty has been doing over the last 12 months, but thats all it should be, not under the command of Europe

  7. Amen
  8. Really. Was that post for comic effect, or were you just spouting balls? The French have taken casualties in AFGN , and have got in there and done their bit, though not members of NATO. Which will be changing soon.

    I'm all for a pop at the French, it's traditional. In the context of this conflict, it is not fair on them and fails to recognise they have lost people fighting too.
  9. What a load of sh1te. BJT are you just trying to get a rise. As for other Euro-nations not taking the hits perhaps one should ask that question of the recently appointed Dutch CDS. He lost his son in AFG on the day he assumed his appointment.
  10. And of course it begs the question of when exactly NATO became the US Empire? Member states still have the final say on when, where and with what constraints they deploy their armed forces. Just because two of them said, "Yee-Hah!" doesn't commit the rest to follow suit.

    I don't hear any pressing demands to deploy Brits in support of French troops in their African hotspots. Sauce for the goose.
  11. I think a few more nations servicemen and women are taking casualties than you think, BJT. What is perhaps lacking is a common purpose and leadership within NATO, but that has always been the same. Each nation will protect its own interests.
  12. Last I heard was the Germans were not allowed to engage in a combat role and were spending their time in their newly constructed bar - much to their disappointment. They are soldiers and want to do what they trained for. They have taken a few casualties, as I found out when I stumbled across some tribute clips to the fallen on youtube.
  13. Perhaps we should be looking at it from the other side and asking why the British government is so willing to put our troops into harms way at the drop of a hat while the other governments are more interested in their own troops' welfare.
  14. I apologise if I'm out of line here, but I thought as far as NATO was concerned 'an attack on one was an attack on all'' therefore we went into Afghanistan after the US was attacked 9/11? So surely that would be different than helping France sort out it's colonial past in Africa?

    It does seem (and obviously I'm old and dim) but as a 1960/70' Wren, NATO's then objective was to stop Eastern Europe invading Western Europe via Germany. It does look at times, that now this threat has gone(?) that some members of NATO are now taking a back seat.

    Please correct me - I'm sure you will!
  15. And you know all about the 24 MEU KIA in Helmand?

    If its not reported it doesn't mean it isn't happening.