Advertising-Free ARRSE

Discussion in 'ARRSE: Site Issues' started by Bad CO, Jun 8, 2012.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. Yes, although I think your pricing is too low

    4 vote(s)
  2. Yes, pricing is spot on

    14 vote(s)
  3. Not unless you reduce the price

    7 vote(s)
  4. Nope, happy to see ARRSE paid for by adverts

    53 vote(s)
  1. Bad CO

    Bad CO LE Admin Reviews Editor Gallery Guru

    Following on from the general discussions about ARRSE sans advertising, we think we're in a position to do this but wanted to discuss pricing. Our initial thoughts were based on a quarterly subscription with £10 as the base figure with discounts for longer terms so:

    • 3 months = £10.00 (or £3.33 per month)
    • 6 months = £18.00 (or £3.00 per month)
    • 12 months = £30.00 (or £2.50 per month)

    What are your thoughts - outrageously expensive, better discounts for longer periods, too little?

    Note that this would remove all advertising except that in the ARRSEpedia and search results. Last 50 would be ad free though.

    Edit - I should have mentioned that this would only ever be optional. There would always be a free version with ads!
  2. Excellent Bad CO, I think your pricing is perhaps a little (but only a little mind) low, I was thinking that the £4-£5 per month sort of level would be about right.

    Just out of interest, and far more importantly would financial contributors get a funky new medal next to their Avatar?
  3. I get porn for that kind of money you know! I am indifferent, the ads don't bother me much tbh.

    Sent from my iPhone using ARRSE app
  4. I agree with a little 'gizzit'. Otherwise, what are subscribers gaining that they can't gain by using Adblocker?

    I think the prices look fair. Too much and it just puts folk off. Too little and the site loses too much money.
  5. The ads could be put in using popunders for those that don't subscribe.

    Thought has to be put in as to what happens when a subscriber is banned as well.
  6. Apart from the current issue of the latest post in a thread having an advert in the text area, the adverts don't bother me. In fact, some are amusing or even useful.

    Viceroy has a good idea, though. A subscribed version with snippets of porn instead of adverts...
  7. No problems paying that!
  8. skid2

    skid2 LE Book Reviewer

    Can it be payable through something as simple as paypal?

    While I have my computer/tablet/stupid head on. I don't get any ads on my tablet, but happy to contribute.
  9. I buy enough shoes and crap from Amazon to keep us all in business.

    Love from Imelda xxxx
  10. Do you do forces discount?
    • Like Like x 8
    • Funny Funny x 1
  11. oldbaldy

    oldbaldy LE Moderator Good Egg (charities)
    1. Battlefield Tours

    & what about pensioner discount. :)
  12. Auld-Yin

    Auld-Yin LE Reviewer Book Reviewer Reviews Editor

    I voted 'No' in the poll above, although I would have no problems in paying a fee for ARRSE, and not just to get rid of adverts.

    I think it would create a two tiered ARRSE membership with some people thinking that because they have paid a small amount that they now own ARRSE and are entitled to do what they like. Everyone on ARRSE should be on the same terms. It is bad enough now with people accusing others of being civvies (even some who are actually civvies) and not being entitled to have a say.

    The ads can be a pain at times, but they are not too intrusive (except the one in the last post on a page :( ) and if people can't work round them, how do they get on with other sites where the ads are very intrusive and almost take over the site, like some newspaper sites.

    To be honest, with the exception again of the last post ad, I don't really notice them unless someone starts a thread about ads! :)

    If there are to be fees then it should be across the board. Guests can browse (with ads) but if you want to put your oar in then you are required to cough up for the privilege.

    One good side to this is it would cut down on the number of sock-puppets that the site is sometimes bothered with. Bad side is it may discourage membership, although in the past many have said they have browsed for a long time before joining when they see a topic they wish to have a say on, so that may stay the same.

    Last question, would the fee be per person or per sign-in username? F'rinstance can a person paying the fee have more than one sign in? There are people who have more than one sign in for genuine reasons - do they have to pay twice (or more :) )?
    • Like Like x 4
  13. Wordsmith

    Wordsmith LE Book Reviewer

    Have you considered a 'premium' membership system? If you're a premium member you get:

    -- Storage for 1,000 PM's (ordinary members restricted to say 50)
    -- Unlimited posts (ordinary members restricted to say 100 a month)
    -- 'Premium' chat room (separate from existing chat room)
    -- Etc.

    I suspect that if you put a blanket membership fee in place, the site will go into a slow decline as existing marginal members decide they don't want to pay the fee, and new members are put off from joining by the fee.

    Having a 'premium' membership may give a boost to site income while still keeping a large membership base.

    • Like Like x 1
    • Dislike Dislike x 1
  14. If we paid as per your suggestion would the This Tribe and Kit Reviews adverts also be removed?

    We already have the donation system of medals etc., all very nice, and what I like about it is that it does not appear to provide any special status or protection from ROP's etc.!

    I do not believe that normal subscibing members should get anything else, the lack of adverts would be reward enough if they really did not like them so much.
  15. Good CO

    Good CO LE Admin

    The theme is running and ready to go, and yes without This Tribe ads and the advert tabs at the top (keeping Rum Ration, Rear Party, E-Goat(not us BTW) and KitReviews as friendly sites rather than adverts, although they could also go if requested).

    The only remaining advertising is in the ARRSEPedia, which as a different piece of software won't obey the user settings on the main site, and the quick search results from searching using the box in the header bar.

    It would be good to throw in some extras, although I don't know what really. ARRSE members already have storage for 1000 PMs for example, rather than the Vbulletin default of 100, so not much to be gained by offering more. Larger avatars would just distort the theme for all so not a good plan. We could allow larger signatures, but once that would be counter-productive. A private forum? An extra light work-friendly theme? And of course sharks with frickin lasers.
    • Like Like x 1