Abrams are going to Afghanistan.

Discussion in 'Afghanistan' started by Abdiel, Nov 19, 2010.

Welcome to the Army Rumour Service, ARRSE

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial military website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. Grumblegrunt

    Grumblegrunt LE Book Reviewer

    the canucks have taken to using them to move around in as they have pretty good mine resistance and compare price wise to the new expensive toys. plus they have the love tube to share with any irate locals who take offense.

    the USMC have admitted they spent a lot of cash on the up armoured humvee, they cant sell them and it isnt suitable for the ied threat. with no money for new kit they are probably trying to make do.

    there are still a 1000 m113's in kuwait just sat there. (at least I think its a thousand - but I know its a lot)
  2. Even so, it will be interesting to see how the powers that be decide to use MBT's in a counter insurgency. This will either prove to be a great idea or it will fall flat on it's face. Possible use on CLP's maybe? I can't think of many other uses.
  3. jim24

    jim24 Book Reviewer

  4. Bad CO

    Bad CO LE Admin Reviews Editor Gallery Guru

    The Danish have (had?) some Leopards deployed as part of TFH. I gather canister was particularly effective!
  5. I remember the Danes having Leopards while we were out there (more so because a leopard came to drag our WMIK out after getting bogged in for hours during driver training on rsoi). I can see the pro's regarding the use of armour, but in the wrong hands they could upset a hell of a lot of people. I'm sure it's a case of rather having them than not though.
  6. About bloody time too!
    MoD are you awake? Or will we continue playing the touchy feely card while counting corpses?
    Fighting wars 101: Dominate the ground, etc, then play good guy.
    Get CR2 out there and more WR. Escalation? Yes! Win the fight then win the peace(1)

    (1)Plus all other clichés natch.
  7. OldSnowy

    OldSnowy LE Moderator Book Reviewer

    Their ability as an OP alone is pretty impressive. Plus comms, firepower, and armour (sorry, Armor).

    There are large areas of Helmand and beyond that are pretty near perfect Tank country - it would make sense to use them there. Or, like the Danes, as overwatch/OPs, or like the Canucks, proving routes and overwatch. They are pretty versatile things, and 2 will fit in an Antonov easily enough :)
  8. meridian

    meridian LE Good Egg (charities)

    It will be interesting to see the arguments about the terrain not being suitable, not wanting th send the wrong message etc etc when in reality we all know the only reason CR2 wasn't and isn't there is COST

    Makes the promises from politicians of all colours about giving the troops everything they need seem like yet more bollox wrapped in a flag
  9. A mate of mine was doing PMC work near the Syrian border a couple of years back and showed me photos one on high ground at an op. It gave them a hell of a lot of firepower should some one get upperty. On the photos it stuck out like a sore thumb though and made a lovely target. Wouldnt like to be sat near it when the iraqis decided to lob mortars at it.
  10. I've always wondered this, if nothing else they lend an immediate support role don't they? Rather than wait on fast air or guns, couldn't the patrol/convoy commander tap on the hatch, point out the target and leave them to it?
  11. My bold - Who the Taliban?!
  12. Just an educated opinion regarding that armour and counter insurgency tend not to go hand in hand. I'm not dismissing the idea as piss poor, as has been posted ref MBT's being used as mobile OP's seems logical from a broard ISTAR perspective. My only concern (and don't take this the wrong way jumpinjarhead) would be eighteen year old US Marines blowing the shit out of civpop and in doing so losing valuable human int when they start to turn back to the taliban.
    There is no such thing as a useless commodity, you just sometimes need to think through it's uses...

  13. Also, I'm guessing that if the ao can accommodate them than they will provide one hell of a boost to any FSG...
  14. If your getting malleted from a building I'd rather one of these put a HEAT round (or whatever its called) through the front door than wait for fast air.