A fifth of teachers back the return of corporal punishment

Are you in favour of bringing the cane back to school?

  • Yes

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • No

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
#1
BBC LINK

Well, well. Looks like there's some common sense at the chalkface after all. No surprise that the NUT is dead against it.

From a personal perspective, we see young people coming to Uni badly prepared for study; they have little or no practical experience in shifting for themselves and getting them to focus on studies is a real chore for the academic staff. Bear in mind that we're a highly selective institution and I can only imagine the problems those lower down the food chain experience.

One thing I was surprised at was the objections amongst Primary School teachers. Surely those pupils are the very ones least susceptible to reasoned explanation and most in need of a hard line. As the twig is bent, and so forth.
 
#3
Reversionary_Modes said:
Never did me any harm. I've been into S&M since age 7.
Me too. Their school trousers were particularly good, IIRC.
 
#4
1 in 5 teachers may back it but I'd bet 5 in 5 human rights lawyers back it. It'd be a massive earner for them in the Euro courts.

Best to start by giving teachers some practical methods of punishing kids. Currently, there is absolutely nothing that they can do. They can't force kids into detention and it seems to be virtually impossible to get them expelled, even if they're extremely violent.

Some sort of borstal might be the way to go with wayward kids. Let them go home at night, if they're good. If not, they get to stay the night in a dormitory in the bottom bunk below a fledgling axe murderer who wets the bed. For the really naught boys, there's always the threat of a trip to the greenhouse!
 
#5
Some sort of borstal might be the way to go with wayward kids. Let them go home at night, if they're good. If not, they get to stay the night in a dormitory in the bottom bunk below a fledgling axe murderer who wets the bed. For the really naught boys, there's always the threat of a trip to the greenhouse![/quote]

I seem to remember from my distant youth being threatened with "Reform School" if ever I got found out. I believe they were like low key borstals for.
On another level, a mate of mine, in the late 50s, was caught in villainy and sentenced to 24 hours at a sort of attendance centre. For 12 weeks on a Saturday morning he had to go and do an hour's PT and an hour's carpentry. He hated it but still ended up in Borstal.
 
#6
Get ém back in on a Sat and Sun for a bit of remedial work.

If they don´t turn up, for any reason, then off to Borstal for a month. 3rd offence in a year sees them in Borstal for the reamainder of that year. Second time for the rest of their school life.

That will learn them, and the bruises can heal by the time they return to the "world". :twisted:

Every county could have a slack handful of tempory borstals(reform schools), and permanent borstals.

Young Offenders would go to different borstals.

Likewise, suspended students could end up there (after a number of incidents), and all expelled students would go to Borstal by default.

Borstal would be a true military style lifestyle. Early to rise, late to bed, all good charachter building stuff.
 
#7
chocolate_frog said:
Get ém back in on a Sat and Sun for a bit of remedial work.

If they don´t turn up, for any reason, then off to Borstal for a month. 3rd offence in a year sees them in Borstal for the reamainder of that year. Second time for the rest of their school life.

That will learn them, and the bruises can heal by the time they return to the "world". :twisted:

Every county could have a slack handful of tempory borstals(reform schools), and permanent borstals.

Young Offenders would go to different borstals.

Likewise, suspended students could end up there (after a number of incidents), and all expelled students would go to Borstal by default.

Borstal would be a true military style lifestyle. Early to rise, late to bed, all good charachter building stuff.
Some LEA's have attendence centres that are supposed to do this role, I have got to hand it to the staff, they are saints , but by the time you "go centre" in most cases you appear irrediamable.

Trotsky
 
#8
I knew Cpl Punishment, I wish he'd return as well, the cnut owes me £100.

I heard he was posted (Assigned :roll: ) to 27 Regt RLC in 02, does anyone know him?
 
#10
As I've said elsewhere here, I got all my schooling in Scotland in the 70s. The belt, tawse, whatever one cares to call it, was a fact of life. Rather more for boys than girls, but girls were not immune. I don't reckon it did any harm. Now, in Central Europe, especially amongst older people who went to school in Communist times, well, to say they are shocked when I tell them that was a usual part of school life, is an understatement. They definitely were doing something right, because when I came here shortly after the fall of said regime, young people were decent and respectable. Not so now, as they slide into the routines and "values" which are the "civilised world". Maybe the threats, passive and implied though they may have been sometimes, from the regime upon parents filtered down, but I'm inclined to believe that at root, from day one in school, kids were inculcated with a few values that are worth inculcating. No violence necessary.
 
#12
It should be there as a deterent,if you cross the line you're gonna get it.

Unfortunately as we are not even allowed to give our own kids a fcukin good and proper bashin at home when they misbehave,there's no way they're going to allow the teachers to hit our kids with a stick.
 
#13
According to studies, caning perverts the mind of both the beater and the beaten.

Just one more reason to bring it back.
 
#14
Given the kicking I'd have given any teacher who tried something like that with me, I can't see it as a way forward. Also worth wondering if those one in five are the same one in five who can't teach for shit. The first senior school I want to the teachers presided over an animal house, but in the second it was, aside from the odd cheeky git and scuffle, great. The difference was the teacher: 9-3:15 holiday grabing card-stampers in the first, (mostly) diamonds who really cared in the second.
 
#15
Ah, yes. I remember the glint in the eye and the lump in the trousers of the deputy head as he swung his treasured weapon aloft.

We shouldn't react with violence. This is retrograde. Let's keep on the road to eventual civilisation and not go back there, please.
 
#16
This theme actually comes up with regularity here and in the press. To an extent it is true that cash attracts brains and talent ( I say "to an extent", because real brains are hooked into a different league altogether). Were the gub really inerested in bringing us to an educactional status better than "the monkeys of Europe", they would put alot of cash into improving the education system. They haven't, they won't and there is a clear reason why not. Fools are easy to govern. Get fools to teach and you have a guaranteed educational spiral. The kind of people who think that their minions need know nothing are to be watched closely indeed.
 
#18
The Mademoiselle inquired if anyone in class could write ' the potato ' in french upon the blackboard. I duly walked up and wrote ' Le spud '

An immediate riot ensued in class followed by her instruction to report to the Head Master, Horace Padfield.

I had to sit on the steps outside the gym to cool my arrse down.

Hit for six.
 
#19
JoseyWales said:
The Mademoiselle inquired if anyone in class could write ' the potato ' in french upon the blackboard. I duly walked up and wrote ' Le spud '

An immediate riot ensued in class followed by her instruction to report to the Head Master, Horace Padfield.

I had to sit on the steps outside the gym to cool my arrse down.

Hit for six.
While I'm sure you were a little **** at school ( :wink: ), not exactly a proportional punishment was it?
 
#20
parapauk said:
Given the kicking I'd have given any teacher who tried something like that with me, I can't see it as a way forward. Also worth wondering if those one in five are the same one in five who can't teach for s***. The first senior school I want to the teachers presided over an animal house, but in the second it was, aside from the odd cheeky git and scuffle, great. The difference was the teacher: 9-3:15 holiday grabing card-stampers in the first, (mostly) diamonds who really cared in the second.
No you wouldn't so stop larging yourself up.
 

Similar threads

New Posts

Latest Threads

Top