-
12-03-2009, 01:40 #16
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
Sorry Bugsy.
Have to disagree old spud, there hasn't been a lot of socialism floating around Europe in the last 2000 years to speak of apart from the late 20th Century.
Might even say modern socialism /communism developed in concert with the industrial revoulution. You didn't need a trade union till there was a mass of workers in one place to be unionised. Trotskyites actively encouraged rural folk to work in the factories...so they could indoctrinate/educate more people. Or so the members of the CP told me and I guessed they would know.
The back gardens and allotments of Poland fed a good deal of all the soviet state with it's black market produce, that is capitalism in action, making a few extra quid for you and your kids by getting off your arse and doing the do.
But it is nice to have a big squishy socialist conceived national health service. Yin and Yang.
As long as people want to flog each other stuff capitalism will survive.
As long as people with a conscience want to protect those less fortunate so will socialism also survive.
Don't you agree?
-
12-03-2009, 10:10 #17Senior Member
- Join Date
- Dec 2007
- Posts
- 1,816
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
Good quick summation of the two systems,...but philosophically the question is:
Originally Posted by corridor_of_Powers
Why is the lust for material things (the heart of capitalism) so strong in some people (limited resources, unlimited greed)?
Once one has basic decent shelter, food etc. having 'more' does not make much sense.
-
12-03-2009, 10:20 #18
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
We are finite creature's and well aware that our time is short and so want to make the most of it.
Originally Posted by KevinB
This arguement is actually rooted in philosophy.I've got your mothers maiden name tattooed on my arm.
-
12-03-2009, 10:29 #19
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
The future of capitalism can be guaranteed by human nature.
Socialism is merely an ideology.
-
12-03-2009, 10:39 #20Senior Member

- Join Date
- Oct 2006
- Location
- 14 miles West of the moon, for all I know.
- Posts
- 15,616
- Images
- 7
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
I’d tend to the view that you didn’t have a trade union until there was a mass of workers in one place to be unionised, rather than didn't need one. What I’ve read of the social changes following the great plagues leads me to believe that ordinary people needed some way to exert power in defence of their interests, it just wasn’t there until mass casualties gave them a lot more power to move from Lord to Lord for better wages or more land.
Originally Posted by corridor_of_Powers
You’d believe members of the CP? :D Industrialisation has a whole lot of drivers, not least the creation of a pool of labour to shift from agriculture to industry. One of the stranger notions in economics is that it can be somehow ‘wrong’ in economic terms for more people to survive off a plot of land than are strictly necessary to farm it – memory tells me it falls under the heading of ‘overemployment’, but then memory also tells me I was a steely-eyed killer and sex-god, so make of that what you will.
Originally Posted by corridor_of_Powers
Wholeheartedly. The problems we’ve had, in this country at least, stem from the fact that we’ve never been able to find a happy medium but have swung from one extreme to the next. A culture of individualism has its downside.
Originally Posted by corridor_of_Powers
We need people who look to the stars, holding the nation and the world in their hearts but at the same time we need down-to-earth people who can do serious and trying work.
In a definite sense, a country's power and prestige isn't only a reflection of its economic power but also a reflection of its people's quality and morality. Moreover, I think the latter is actually more important in the long-term.
http://www.economist.com/blogs/multi...na_has_changed
-
12-03-2009, 10:52 #21
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
But it is basic human instinct. You may have basic shelter/food ect, but then you want a bigger semi or detached shelter, you want to shop at waitrose or marks instead of aldi and lido. Materialistic improvement has always been an aspiration of human nature.
Originally Posted by KevinB
Help the young child of a serving soldier fight cancer - Go to http://www.justgiving.com/jamie-appeal and give whatever you can
-
12-03-2009, 10:54 #22
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
Which is why you will always be at the bottom of the food chain and remain a loser.
Originally Posted by KevinB
"Remember that you are an Englishman, and have consequently won first prize in the lottery of life".
Cecil Rhodes
-
12-03-2009, 11:02 #23
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
:D
Originally Posted by Ord_Sgt
The answer is well described by Abraham Maslow back in the 60's with his pyramid of needs concept.
-
12-03-2009, 11:04 #24
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
The fundamental problem of socialism is that is starts with the wrong premise. It's a political and economic ideology which argues for providing everyone with an equitable share of wealth (through the proletariat's seizure of the means of production etc etc).
The point of capitalism is that a free market economy empowers people to create wealth. To do this they have to take risks. Now we can, and should (in the current circumstances) argue about what represents an acceptable level of risk taking. That said, risk taking isn't just done by bankers and stock brokers; it's also done by anyone who takes a loan to buy a house, or to set up a business.
The problem facing modern socialists is the same one facing socialists in any other period: it's balls. Nationalisation, the sharing of wealth, centralised planning and allocation of resources prevents wealth creation, or slows it drastically. The Soviet Union fell for a number of reasons, but they key one was that it could not sustain itself economically. It's people could not use what resources they had to create wealth which would then percolate through society.
Contrast that with the UK since 1979. Yes we're no in a recession arguably precipitated by an under-regulated capitalist system. But remember the ride we took? Think how things changed in 20 years, and how much better off we all were because of wealth creation which we all benefitted from.
Socialists might like to think their time has come. And we'd be idiots to help them in that fantasy.During the evacuation of Crete Admiral Cunningham was determined that the "Navy must not let the Army down". When Army officers expressed concerns that he would lose too many ships, Cunningham said that "It takes three years to build a ship, it takes three centuries to build a tradition".
-
12-03-2009, 11:15 #25
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
trouble is the bold risk taking of capitalism
went way way to far and fecked everything up.
leaving the market to sort itself out is the exact oppasite of soviet style planning and as effective. without state intervention we might all be in a much much worse state.
controlled capitalism is probably the best we can do for the moment bankers won't like having to pay more taxes and having there "clever" ideas veoted
but tough should'nt have been caught skinny dipping as buffet said :(
unfettered capitalism is no better for the majority of people than socialism
nice in theory
but we need banksOn a Hot morning in cyprus I found the meaning of anger. Fortunataly I was comftably numb.
The RSM and various other NCO's seemed very agitated.
maybe they should look into counselling?
-
12-03-2009, 11:24 #26Senior Member
- Join Date
- Sep 2006
- Posts
- 6,277
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
'Problems' with British Socialists:
Brown, Harman, Hain, Hewitt, Hodge, Miliband(s), Balls, Cooper, Bliar, Mrs Bliar, Prescott, Smith J, Woodward, Woolas, 'Mr' West, Malloch-Brown and everyone's chum Mandelson.
Coupled with out-dated dogma and a lack of serious intellect anywhere within the system, these are but a small example of their 'problems'.
Add in horrendously flawed policies and criminally poor judgement and the 'problems' start to speak for themselves.
-
12-03-2009, 11:32 #27
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
So...all you clever Capitalist supporters/fans should be able to explain: where has all the money gone?
-
12-03-2009, 11:36 #28
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
Nowhere, loads of it is still in my bank account.
Originally Posted by telecaster
"Remember that you are an Englishman, and have consequently won first prize in the lottery of life".
Cecil Rhodes
-
12-03-2009, 11:42 #29
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
I have spent a lot of it personnally - saw it as a civic duty to support the economy.....plenty more left but not enough time for toy research at the moment.
Originally Posted by telecaster

-
12-03-2009, 11:46 #30
Re: The problems facing modern Socialists
Blair is not a socialist no way no how
scapped clause 4
PFI etc etc.
is a kunt not a socalist whole of nulabor are not that was the whole point of nulabour
On a Hot morning in cyprus I found the meaning of anger. Fortunataly I was comftably numb.
The RSM and various other NCO's seemed very agitated.
maybe they should look into counselling?
-


LinkBack URL
About LinkBacks




Reply With Quote








Bookmarks