• Andy McNab - The ARRSE Interview.

      A week ago, on Tuesday last, I had the pleasure of interviewing Andy McNab ( other names are available) about his latest book, 'Battle Lines'. Luckily it was a telephone interview, so I didn't have to don the black nasty to obscure my features, and a voice change wasn't required.

      Now, first thing I have to say is that he is a very nice guy and extraordinarly easy to chat to.Clearly a very bright bloke and certainly has talent, but then, that goes with being part of an elite, a unit that is the envy of the world, but sadly the Royal Greenjackets are no more, so he has to make do with the other rag tag outfit he went to.


      I did tape the chat, on two seperate dictaphones, including one with a clever device that attaches to the telephone, but I seem to have cocked that up somehow, so most of the chat is from memory..

      I started by asking what the book - 'Battle Lines' was about, and what was different to his other books. Andy said that this one related very much to the families that wait at home when the troops are deployed, the stresses and strains that the wives and children feel, the struggles they have with the ordinary and the mundane. How small things become huge problems and how isolated they feel from their partners. He had spent considerable time visiting, both with deployed and resting troops, and with their families, asking about the problems, getting a feel for what it was like for those left behind, along with his writing partner, Kym Jordan, and believed he had a small inkling into how the families felt.

      Another area he was interested to explore was the reaction of partners and families to those who came back injured, especially from I.E.D injuries, and in this he had the help of Headley Court and other places. He tries to convey the frutrations and obstacles encountered both by the injured party and their families, the psychological problems that can occur as well as the physical.

      From the deployed troops perspective, he has explored the communication difficulties, and the frustrations that can be found with not being able to talk with your loved ones. We now take for granted the e mail facilities, the satphones and even mobile 'phones, and in an earlier time, the old-fashioned bluey, or even ( prehistorically) the handwritten letter! The anxiety that is felt by both sides when the comms systems are locked down, following an incident and the anger that can be felt by not being able to tell your partner that you are safe, and the sheer terror that the families feel, not knowing what has happened and who is the victim.

      Andy tells me that he spent time with a rifle coy from 2 Rifles on Herrick, trying to get a feel for what the troops think, how they feel and how they deal with the stresses of families left behind, the seemingly minute and irritating problems that are mindless to blokes in the field, constantly under threat to their life and limb. The simple things, like car tax, nursery school and so on; the minutae of life have no - at least very little - relevance when under fire, or walking carefully and slowly along a dusty track, hoping that at the end you will still be alive and whole, but to those at home, these minor things assume a life of their own. If your husband/boyfriend has always taken care of things, how do you cope when the washing machine breaks? What should you do when you get a parking ticket? McNab and Jordan do cover this dilemma well and there is huge empathy.

      But, for you, when in a FoB, or patrolling, how do you cope when your wife is the subject of gossip? How can you deal with rumours that she is over the side? Especially if you are unable to talk to her, if comms are down, or you can't get a quiet time to talk. Even if others eem to and whisper in your ear the scandals that their own partners pass on to them.

      Leaving his latest book for a moment, we talked about other things; he is a frequent reader ( and sometimes contributor to ) Arrse. He was interested in the recent debate on the Lee Child character, Reacher, and the casting of Tom Cruise. He was quite of the same opinion as most of us on that subject, and as he had talked with Child, and discovered that the physical description of Reacher was based on Lawrence Dallaglio, he echoed our thoughts, to a degree.

      I asked if there were any plans to film his books, and he told me that it was happening even now. The casting for his hero, Nick Stone, is ongoing, with Jason Statham, Tom Hardy and Joel Kinneman ( The Killing, USA version) as possibles.

      Andy also told me that he is used as a consultant by some Very Senior army officers, as well as the MoD and they also visit our site frequently. It is seen as a sounding board, an indicator of how the troops think and feel, and considered a Good Thing by those in the towers of power.

      During our chat we spoke of many things but concentrated on the new book, and it was sheer happenstance that it arrived as I was talking to him, and so I read it. The review will follow.

      We did touch on the supposed furore that followed the publication of 'Bravo Two Zero' and he told me that he had been effectively asked to write it, that he had recieved total and utter cooperation from all parties and both the Regiment and the MoD had seen the advacnce drafts. They were happy and had no problems, and the supposed outrage was manufactured by the press with no foundation in truth. Now, I know that it will come as a surprise to us all that the popular press would be less than honest about things, but it does happen! Andy was quite happy about it, since it was publicity that couldn't be bought, and all publicity can be useful. It certainly helped the sale of the book, and he hasn't done badly since.

      In summary, a nice bloke, and someone i would be happy to have a pint with, as i suspect so would most of you.
      This article was originally published in forum thread: Andy McNab; The interview. started by old_fat_and_hairy View original post
      Comments 84 Comments
      1. bluntslane's Avatar
        bluntslane -
        Very informative, a useful insight into Mr McNabs writing. Nice of O,F&H to share his technology difficulties with us, shows self-deprecation,confidence and/or humility.
      1. PepperSeaDog's Avatar
        PepperSeaDog -
        Quote Originally Posted by old_fat_and_hairy View Post
        he is a frequent reader ( and sometimes contributor to ) Arrse.
        You can't just leave it at that you tease!
      1. mac1's Avatar
        mac1 -
        There seems to have been a transformation on views of McNab on Arrse; not so long ago, posters couldn't slag him off enough. Similar seems to have happened with the subject of the United States.
      1. bluntslane's Avatar
        bluntslane -
        mac1, I've never slagged him off, but then again I've never met him, just read his books.
      1. CptDanjou's Avatar
        CptDanjou -
        Quote Originally Posted by bluntslane View Post
        mac1, I've never slagged him off, but then again I've never met him, just read his books.
        I`d guess most of us have / do.
      1. Barry Buddon's Avatar
        Barry Buddon -
        Quote Originally Posted by mac1 View Post
        There seems to have been a transformation on views of McNab on Arrse; not so long ago, posters couldn't slag him off enough. Similar seems to have happened with the subject of the United States.
        Don't let it get you down big guy , they don't mean it
      1. bluntslane's Avatar
        bluntslane -
        Quote Originally Posted by Barry Buddon View Post
        Don't let it get you down big guy , they don't mean it
        Barry that's clever, I missed that first time round.
      1. filthyphil's Avatar
        filthyphil -
        "During our chat we spoke of many things but concentrated on the new book, and it was sheer happenstance that it arrived as I was talking to him, and so I read it. "

        It was bloody decent of him to wait on the phone until you finished.
      1. Barry Buddon's Avatar
        Barry Buddon -
        Quote Originally Posted by bluntslane View Post
        Barry that's clever, I missed that first time round.
        The clues are all there bud. I just found a thread he started titled 'Anyone else wish Goatherders would just fuck off?'
        Another one called 'Whats best to sing when getting a fearsome kicking off jundies ? The Jam or The Clash ?'

        Then there was a reply to someone worried about Iraqi Special Forces : 'I've had worse kickings in Tidworth to be honest'
      1. bluntslane's Avatar
        bluntslane -
        Quote Originally Posted by Barry Buddon View Post
        The clues are all there bud. I just found a thread he started titled 'Anyone else wish Goatherders would just fuck off?'
        Another one called 'Whats best to sing when getting a fearsome kicking off jundies ? The Jam or The Clash ?'

        Then there was a reply to someone worried about Iraqi Special Forces : 'I've had worse kickings in Tidworth to be honest'
        Fair one, no-one ever accused me of being the sharpest chisel mate.
      1. Barry Buddon's Avatar
        Barry Buddon -
        Pm him asking for the time , if he bangs on about baby G or Traser its the product placing cunt himself

        I'd hate to be strangled to death by a deniable operator only to notice their lemon baby G as the lights went out
      1. bluntslane's Avatar
        bluntslane -
        Quote Originally Posted by Barry Buddon View Post
        Pm him asking for the time , if he bangs on about baby G or Traser its the product placing cunt himself

        I'd hate to be strangled to death by a deniable operator only to notice their lemon baby G as the lights went out
        A truly dreadful last earthly sight and one, surely, that would debar you from the drinking hall of Valhalla.
      1. guzzijon's Avatar
        guzzijon -
        Quote Originally Posted by old_fat_and_hairy View Post
        Now, first thing I have to say is that he is a very nice guy and extraordinarly easy to chat to.Clearly a very bright bloke and certainly has talent, but then, that goes with being part of an elite, a unit that is the envy of the world, but sadly the Royal Greenjackets are no more, so he has to make do with the other rag tag outfit he went to.
        Good lad. What is this 'other unit' of which you speak?
      1. Glad_its_all_over's Avatar
        Glad_its_all_over -
        Quote Originally Posted by guzzijon View Post
        Good lad. What is this 'other unit' of which you speak?
        That'd be 161 Messtin Rivet Replacement Troop, a key element of 12 Messtin Repair Battalion. A proud unit with a long and honourable tradition. I gather the man also spent some time in an Adventurous Training unit somewhere.
      1. DrStealth's Avatar
        DrStealth -
        Quote Originally Posted by PepperSeaDog View Post
        You can't just leave it at that you tease!
        he posts under the moniker 'Stacker1'......
      1. muzzleflash's Avatar
        muzzleflash -
        Quote Originally Posted by DrStealth View Post
        he posts under the moniker 'Stacker1'......
        And here's me thinking he was Afghan Kandak....................
      1. mickali's Avatar
        mickali -
        Quote Originally Posted by PepperSeaDog View Post
        You can't just leave it at that you tease!
        I'm Andy McNabb, but do not IM me I will not respond. B20 Out.
      1. Cabana's Avatar
        Cabana -
        Quote Originally Posted by mickali View Post
        I'm Andy McNabb, but do not IM me I will not respond. B20 Out.
        Don't talk rot!! I am Andy McNabb, and so is my cat!
      1. afghanman's Avatar
        afghanman -
        Quote Originally Posted by mickali View Post
        I'm Andy McNabb, but do not IM me I will not respond. B20 Out.
        Quote Originally Posted by Cabana View Post
        Don't talk rot!! I am Andy McNabb, and so is my cat!
        Lets not start this merry dickdance please. I am Andy McNabb and I have attached a couple of pics to back up my story (or Legend as we call it in H)



        Me on Ops in some desert. We call our landrovers 'Pink Panthers'



        Me on ops in Berkshire
      1. Hellmans's Avatar
        Hellmans -
        Three Andy McNab walts in a row and you can't even spell the fecking name properly! One 'B'