View Poll Results: What was / is your (highest) substantive rank?

Voters
310. You may not vote on this poll
  • Private / O Cdt

    45 14.52%
  • JNCO

    71 22.90%
  • SNCO

    98 31.61%
  • Jnr Offr (to Capt)

    39 12.58%
  • Snr Offr (to Col)

    34 10.97%
  • Field Offr

    23 7.42%
Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 23
Discuss ARRSE Poll 2009 - Rank (if serving or retired) at the ARRSE: Site Issues forum within the The Army Rumour Service website; Originally Posted by right-grumpy Staff Officer = Colonel and up In which Army is this?...
  1. #11
    Moderator Sixty's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    Staggering about making free with my lewd and lascivious boasts.
    Posts
    8,334

    Re: ARRSE Poll 2009 - Rank (if serving or retired)

    Quote Originally Posted by right-grumpy
    Staff Officer = Colonel and up
    In which Army is this?
    "You've really worked out your banter haven't you?"

    "No, not really. This is a different thing; it's spontaneous and it's called 'wit'"

  2. #12
    Junior Member donquixotedelamanche's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Posts
    7

    Re: ARRSE Poll 2009 - Rank (if serving or retired)

    Ummm... the answer is actually tricky...

    Staff Officers form A, G, & Q and can be almost any rank, at any level within the hierarchy (technically).

    However, the expression "Staff Officers" colloquially refers to Officers employed within a "Command Staff" and is generally applied as follows...

    A military staff is a group of officers and enlisted personnel that provides a bi-directional flow of information between a commanding officer and subordinate military units.

    Officers oversee staff sections, Senior Enlisted Personnel task personnel in the maintenance of tactical equipment and vehicles. Senior Analysts are tasked with the finalizing of reports, and enlisted personnel participate in the acquisition of information from subordinate staffs and units.

    The purpose of a military staff is mainly that of providing accurate, timely information which by category represents information on which command decisions are based. The key application is that of decisions that effectively manage unit resources. While information flow toward the commander is a priority, information that is useful or contingent in nature is communicated to lower staffs and units.

    This definition above, of course, means that CQMS / SQMS / BQMS etc along with others are technically Staff Officers, but;

    Within the UK Army, the following definitions apply...

    GSO1. General Staff Officer (1st Class). The chief of staff, graded a lieutenant colonel or colonel. He was in charge of the General Staff Branch, responsible for training, intelligence, planning operations and directing the battle as it progressed. Most orders from the GOC General Officer Commanding were actually written up and signed by the GSO1.[1]

    GSO2. General Staff Officer (2nd Class). The deputy chief of staff, graded a major. He assisted the GSO1.

    GSO3. General Staff Officer (3rd Class). Graded a captain. Usually responsible for intelligence.

    Consequently, there is not (AFAIAA) a true definition which could be applied other than generically and incorrectly...

    1) Officers (2Lt / Lt / Capt = Troop / Platoon / Battery Officers) The implementors of Tactics.
    2) Field Officers (Maj / LtCol = Field Commanders) The Directors and Implementors of Tactics to satisfy the Strategy from above.
    3) Staff Officers (Capt / Maj / LtCol / Col = General('s) Staff) Which actually means "The General's Staff" - i.e. his personal and key Advisors and Implementors of Strategy.
    4) Generals (inc. FM although this now almost an Honoury Rank on retirement) which the Navy also would refer to as Flag Officers.

    All three services Officers of this group get to fly pennants on their personal chariot


    ...but off course there are exceptions!
    Don Quixote de La Manche
    (La Manche ~ The English Channel <> La Mancha ~ a region of Central Spain)

  3. #13
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Posts
    6,345

    Re: ARRSE Poll 2009 - Rank (if serving or retired)

    There's something strange going on here. When I ticked "Field Offr" a box came up that said: "You lying bästard, Bugsy!". :D :D :D

    MsG

  4. #14
    Senior Member RCT(V)'s Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Posts
    1,796

    Re: ARRSE Poll 2009 - Rank (if serving or retired)

    Quote Originally Posted by in_the_cheapseats
    And an explanation of the difference between field and officer splits you have put in.

    Field to me means Maj and above (+ the Adjt) before General rank, starting at Brig.

    Are you equating Field to mean Maj and Lt Col or are you meaning General Rank?
    "in_the_cheapseats", your understanding is the same as mine.

    However, I was happy to comply with the “Good_CO’s” classification.

    I ticked the “Snr Offr (to Col)”, which is how I will henceforth describe myself . . . quoting the “Good CO” as authority !!
    "It is the duty of the dog owner to try to be the great man his dog thinks he is". ("soldernut" 01OCT2010).

    "Happiness is not a destination, it is a manner of traveling". (texas_titans 11DEC2010).

    "You really do have to wonder how much you would have to hate, indeed loathe, your culture, your country and your fellow citizens, before you would even contemplate something like . . . Labour's conspiracy for mass immigration". ("Jaeger", ARRSE, 23OCT2009).

  5. #15
    Moderator elovabloke's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Instow - The Bar
    Posts
    6,645

    Re: ARRSE Poll 2009 - Rank (if serving or retired)

    Quote Originally Posted by Good CO
    So stop being so farkin' pedantic!
    Thats why we get our Warrants
    Coaching done, training done - now she's just got to go out and do it. Brighton Marathon off you go.

    Success is never final and failure never fatal. It's courage that counts.

  6. #16
    Senior Member Queensman's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    2,558

    Re: ARRSE Poll 2009 - Rank (if serving or retired)

    Quote Originally Posted by Disco
    Wheres the Warrants!!
    Warrant Officers are Non Commissioned Officers!
    PRISTINAE VIRTUTIS MEMOR

    Discipline: Discipline is the sacrifice of a man's comforts, inclinations, safety, even life for others, for something greater than himself. It is the refusal to be the weak link in the chain that snaps under pressure.

  7. #17
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Posts
    342

    Re: ARRSE Poll 2009 - Rank (if serving or retired)

    No Cadet option????

    I'll be off!

  8. #18
    Senior Member Queensman's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    2,558

    Re: ARRSE Poll 2009 - Rank (if serving or retired)

    Quote Originally Posted by BevisRory
    No Cadet option????

    I'll be off!
    Yes you better had be off, young man! You clown, have another look at the first option - then don't vote, because you're an Oxygen Tealeaf!
    PRISTINAE VIRTUTIS MEMOR

    Discipline: Discipline is the sacrifice of a man's comforts, inclinations, safety, even life for others, for something greater than himself. It is the refusal to be the weak link in the chain that snaps under pressure.

  9. #19
    Senior Member iamalondoncrab's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Posts
    586

    Re: ARRSE Poll 2009 - Rank (if serving or retired)

    I'd just like to say that as a private, I resent being lumped with the O Cdts, and think we should have our own categories.

    Not to be difficult or anything


    Vote for Change. Pedobear '09

  10. #20
    Senior Member Queensman's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    2,558

    Re: ARRSE Poll 2009 - Rank (if serving or retired)

    Quote Originally Posted by iamalondoncrab
    I'd just like to say that as a private, I resent being lumped with the O Cdts, and think we should have our own categories.

    Not to be difficult or anything
    Officer Cadets are, or at least were in my day, Private soldiers. Paid as such and with an 8 figure number.
    PRISTINAE VIRTUTIS MEMOR

    Discipline: Discipline is the sacrifice of a man's comforts, inclinations, safety, even life for others, for something greater than himself. It is the refusal to be the weak link in the chain that snaps under pressure.

Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •