Army Rumour Service

P: 1, 2, 3 ... 14, 15, 16  >  :| |:

The Intelligence Cell

Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:20 am
Author: spike7451 Location: In Grace Niells
I never found this tw@ funny & this confirms why!

http://express.co.uk/posts/view/136052/EXCLUSIVE-Fans-stunned-as-Jimmy-Carr-insults-our-Afghan-heroes

Quote:


COMEDIAN Jimmy Carr has caused outrage by making a tasteless joke about soldiers wounded in Iraq and Afghanistan.

The controversial comic stunned fans with the ill-timed gag about amputees the day after the launch of this year’s Poppy Appeal.

MPs of all parties last night joined a chorus of ­condemnation with former officers and relatives of the many soldiers who have lost limbs in the fighting.

Downing Street took the unusual step of issuing a statement in response to the furore.

Defence Secretary Bob Ainsworth said: “Our brave Armed Forces put their lives on the line for all of us and deserve the utmost respect.”

There were gasps from the 2,500-strong audience at the Manchester Apollo on Friday night as Carr wrapped up his stand-up routine with the joke: “Say what you like about the servicemen amputees from Iraq and Afghanistan, but we are going to have a ****ing good Paralympics team in 2012.”

Shadow Defence Secretary Liam Fox said: “Our Armed Forces are the first to have a rough and ready sense of humour but this goes beyond the pale.” And Colonel Richard Kemp, a former Commander of British Forces in Afghanistan, branded Carr a “disgrace”.

James Cockburn, stepfather of Marine Ben McBean, who lost an arm and a leg in a Taliban attack in February 2008, said the joke was “in poor taste”.

Ironically, Carr gave Ben, 22, a signed copy of his book when he visited Headley Court rehabilitation centre in Surrey, although the comic left him cold. “Ben thought he was a bit of a numpty,” said Mr Cockburn.

SAS legend Andy McNab said that while Carr has a point – a number of amputee servicemen have been snapped up for the Paralympics because of their athleticism and determination – “it’s not a subject for humour”.

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:30 am
Author: tropper66 Location: cardiff
The sad thing is that its true but most certainly not funny, the stupid cnut

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:33 am
Author: the_boy_syrup
I never like'd the smarmy *
He's got a face you'd never tire of punching


Although I suppose he does have a point still not his place to say it for laughs

* it I'm off to get the outrage bus work tickets whose coming ?

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:34 am
Author: mistersoft Location: Sarkozyland
spike7451:
Ironically, Carr gave Ben, 22, a signed copy of his book when he visited Headley Court rehabilitation centre in Surrey, although the comic left him cold. “Ben thought he was a bit of a numpty,” said Mr Cockburn.

That'll do for me.

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:37 am
Author: terroratthepicnic Location: Old Blighty
Jimmy Carr is a cock anyway. Lets get him on the next CSE, where he can say jokes like that and see if he comes home with all his limbs.

Although to be fair, we will have a blinding Para Olympics team. I can't wait for the first time it's in the press that most of the team where in a pub celebrating when naked bar was called.

Edited: for having mong typing ability

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:45 am
Author: whosthedaddy Location: on the arrse end of a 3 day crack binge trying to do Sudoku upside down in a wind tunnel
Bloody hell, get over yourselves. He's a comedian ffs, and what';s more a comedian who is known for being close to the bone. If you don't like it, dont watch, simples! He makes jokes about many unsavoury topics like rape being surprise sex for example, just like Frankie Boyle making jokes about paedophilia, doesn't mean that he means it personally.

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:46 am
Author: Issi Location: Gower
I can't see the problem really. It's just a joke and I think that he's quite right, we will have a bloody good team in the next Paralympics.

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:48 am
Author: Auld-Yin Location: In front of the fire wearing my slippers
Carr is a smug git, but if that comment had been made on here first then I guaranteed it would have been classed as genius by many.

Might be worth going down Ladbrokes and putting a bet on the number of medals won by Britain at the next Paraolympics. Very Happy

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:48 am
Author: the_boy_syrup
whosthedaddy:
Bloody hell, get over yourselves. He's a comedian ffs, and what';s more a comedian who is known for being close to the bone. If you don't like it, dont watch, simples! He makes jokes about many unsavoury topics like rape being surprise sex for example, just like Frankie Boyle making jokes about paedophilia, doesn't mean that he means it personally.

Ah but Frankie Boyls is funny

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:50 am
Author: polar69
Oh no I am outraged on behalf of people I have never met.

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:50 am
Author: Tremaine
Guardian Review of Mr. Carr

Also on the I.O.S. smuggest Briton's list, deservedly, you might say.

"Jimmy Carr oozes the charm and insincerity of a re-animated Bob Monkhouse". Although Monkhouse, in comparison, could be called genius.

Sick jokes might be viewed as Carr's stock in trade, he's been discussed on these boards already and not too favourably. Either a joke too far or a misfire, it's not funny for his victim nor would the wider audience appreciate the man's obvious desperation for a laugh, at any expense.

That Carr targeted soldiers wounded in Iraq and Afghanistan speaks volumes, and he seriously misjudges their mates, families and supporters.
It will come back to bite him, on his smug arrse.

Perhaps, hopefully, even enough to keep this smug tasteless creep out of mainstream entertainment. Permanently.

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:50 am
Author: CRmeansCeilingReached
guys, i completely agree - forces casualties are not funny.

however, take a look in the NAAFI bar and see some of the groups we routinely rip to death, including the disabled. sure they don't think we're funny either.

if we dish it out so readily, we've got to be able to take it in the spirit it's meant when it comes our way. it's only a joke for fucks sake.

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 8:53 am
Author: Fat_Cav Location: Xanadu . . Somwhere near Reading
As much as I dislike this one-line merchant I believe this was probably a line he picked up from Headley Court from the guys there in rehab and so feels justified in using it Question

BTW the local news here (Meridian) did a piece about the Paralympic training team going to Headley Court and other placers to give the Ex-soldiers/airmen some guidance on fitness for the future with a view to 2012/2016. So as distastful as it may seem to some, I suspect he's more guided and informed than most.

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 9:01 am
Author: the_boy_syrup
CRmeansCeilingReached:
if we dish it out so readily, we've got to be able to take it in the spirit it's meant when it comes our way. it's only a joke for fucks sake.

Yes but we like to sit on the ourage bus arms folded bottom lip sticking out if people offend our delicate feelings

You see we can piss all over the street and make Hitler salutes in Germany but if someone pisses on a memmorial or slags a poppy we take to the outrage bus

It's what we do One Army TA & Regular outraged together and Arsse gives us that platform for us to express our outrage and hurt feelings

If Brown loses the next Election we may have to look at parking up at least 5 outrage buses and their crews

So please let us have a little of these threads Very Happy

Shall we start a countdown to the first Chubb post?

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 9:06 am
Author: Markintime Location: Somewhere north of the Watford Gap
I don't think he was taking the piss out of the soldiers at all and he was pointing out how fit and dedicated these young lads are and how there is still plenty for them to aim for. As has been mooted on here already, I wonder if it's a joke he borrowed off someone at Headley Court, at least he bothered himself to visit which says a lot for him in my book.

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 9:10 am
Author: chocolate_frog Location: Up my own ArRSe
How is this outraging?

He makes jokes like this all the time, about a wide range of people.

You know what you are going to see, when you see him. Admittedly hte timing might be a bit off.

Ever thought it could be a compliment in a cack handed way?

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 9:11 am
Author: classic
Issi:
I can't see the problem really. It's just a joke and I think that he's quite right, we will have a bloody good team in the next Paralympics.

The problem with jokes is the fact that when people are making fun of people who are less able than themselves it hurts and i personally know that.
When a person laugh's with a person over their disability you know its only banter ,But when you have people who laugh's at a person disability this is where the problem's occur.

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 9:13 am
Author: StickyEnd
Markintime:
I don't think he was taking the piss out of the soldiers at all and he was pointing out how fit and dedicated these young lads are and how there is still plenty for them to aim for. As has been mooted on here already, I wonder if it's a joke he borrowed off someone at Headley Court, at least he bothered himself to visit which says a lot for him in my book.

That is pretty much what I was thinking. More of a compliment than an insult.

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 9:13 am
Author: CRmeansCeilingReached
well done the_boy_syrup, there is the chubbmonster right on cue Very Happy

Re: Jimmy Carr Mocks Limbless Soldiers On Stage.

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 9:17 am
Author: Dread Location: Budapest
I thought it was a cracking comment and far better than his usual 'jokes'.

As said earlier in the thread: if said in the NAAFI it would have got the usual idiots posting lots of "ROFL". Comedy often works best when there is an element of truth in the core.

All times are GMT
Page 1 of 16 P: 1, 2, 3 ... 14, 15, 16  >  :| |:
http://www.arrse.co.uk/